Des Plaines River:
the final murders
Gacy later confessed to police that he had initially
considered stowing bodies in his attic, but had been worried about complications
arising from "excessive
leakage". Therefore, he chose
to dispose of his victims off the I-55 Bridge
into the Des Plaines River. Gacy
stated he had thrown five bodies off the I-55
bridge into the Des Plaines River
in 1978, one of which he believed had landed upon a passing barge, although only four of these five bodies were
ever found.
The first known victim was thrown from the I-55 bridge into the Des
Plaines River, 20-year-old Timothy
O'Rourke was killed in mid-June after leaving his Dover Street apartment, having informed his roommate of his intention
to purchase cigarettes; his body was found 6 miles (10 km) downstream on June
30. On November 4, Gacy killed a 19-year-old named Frank Landingin. His body was found in the Des Plaines River on November 12. Less than three weeks later, on
November 24, a 20-year-old Elmwood Park
a youth named James Mazzara
disappeared after sharing Thanksgiving
dinner with his family; his body was found on December 28. The cause of death
in the case of Landingin was certified as suffocation through the youth's own
underwear being lodged down his throat, plugging his airway and effectively
causing him to drown in his own vomit. Mazzara had been strangled with a ligature.
Investigation
On the afternoon of December 11, 1978, Gacy visited a Des Plaines pharmacy to discuss a
potential remodeling deal with the owner of the store, Phil Torf. While Gacy was within earshot of a 15-year-old part-time
employee named Robert Jerome Piest,
he mentioned that his firm hired teenage boys at a starting wage of $5 per
hour—almost double the pay Piest earned at the pharmacy.
After Gacy left the store, Piest told his mother that "some contractor wants to talk to me
about a job". Piest left the store, promising to return shortly. When Piest failed to return, his family filed
a missing person report on their son with the Des Plaines police. The owner of the pharmacy named Gacy as the
contractor Piest had most likely left the store to talk with about a job.
Gacy denied talking to Piest when Des Plaines police visited his home the following evening, indicating
he had seen two youths working at the pharmacy and that he had asked one of
them—whom he believed to be Piest—whether any remodeling materials were present
in the rear of the store. He was adamant, however, that he had not offered
Piest a job and promised to come to the station later that evening to make a
statement confirming this, indicating he was unable to do so at that moment as
his uncle had just died. At 3:20 a.m., Gacy, covered in mud, arrived at the
police station, claiming he had been involved in a car accident.
Upon returning to the police station later that day, Gacy
denied any involvement in the disappearance of Robert Piest and repeated that he had not offered the youth a job.
When asked why he had returned to the pharmacy at 8 p.m. on December 11, Gacy
claimed he had done so in response to a phone call from Phil Torf informing him he had left his appointment book at the store.
Detectives had already spoken with Torf, who had stated he had placed no such
call to Gacy. At the request of
detectives, Gacy prepared a written statement detailing his movements on
December 11.
Des Plaines
police were convinced Gacy was behind Piest's disappearance and checked Gacy's
record, discovering that he had an outstanding battery charge against him in
Chicago and had served a prison sentence in Iowa for the sodomy of a 15-year-old boy. A search of Gacy's house on December 13 was
ordered by a judge at the request of detectives and turned up several
suspicious items: a 1975 Maine West High
School class ring engraved with the initials J.A.S., various driver's licenses, handcuffs, a two-by-four with
holes drilled in the ends, books on homosexuality and pederasty, a syringe,
male clothing too small for Gacy, a 6mm Brevettata starter pistol and a photo
receipt from the pharmacy where Robert
Piest worked. Police decided to confiscate Gacy's Oldsmobile, along with other PDM
vehicles, and assigned two two-man surveillance teams to follow Gacy, while
they continued their investigation of Gacy regarding Piest's disappearance.
The following day, investigators received a phone call from Michael Rossi, who informed the
investigators both of Gregory Godzik's
the disappearance and the fact that another
PDM employee, Charles Hattula, had
been found drowned in an Illinois river the previous year.
On December 15, Des
Plaines investigators obtained further details upon Gacy's battery charge,
learning the complainant, Jeffrey
Rignall had reported that Gacy had lured him into his car, chloroformed
him raped him and dumped him, with severe chest and facial burns and rectal
bleeding, in Lincoln Park the
following morning. In an interview with Gacy's former wife the same day, they
learned of the disappearance of John
Butkovich. The same day, the Maine West High School ring was traced
to a John Alan Szyc. In an interview with Szyc's mother the same
day, she informed officers of the January 1977 disappearance of her son and
that several items from his apartment were also missing, including a Motorola TV set. She added that
investigators had informed her the month following his disappearance that her
son had apparently sold his Plymouth
Satellite to a John Gacy.
Investigators noted that one of Gacy's employees, Michael Rossi, drove a similar car to Szyc's: A check of the VIN
confirmed the car driven by Rossi had belonged to Szyc.
By December 16, Gacy was becoming affable with the
surveillance detectives, regularly inviting them to join him for meals in
various restaurants and occasionally for drinks in bars or within his home. He
repeatedly denied that he had anything to do with Piest's disappearance and
accused the officers of harassing him because of his political connections or
because of his use of recreational drugs. Knowing these officers were unlikely
to arrest him on anything trivial, he openly taunted them by flouting traffic
laws and succeeded in losing his pursuers on more than one occasion.
On December 17, investigators conducted a formal interview
of Michael Rossi, who informed them
Gacy had sold Szyc's vehicle to him with the explanation that he had bought the
car from Szyc because the youth needed money to move to California. A further examination of Gacy's Oldsmobile was conducted on this date. In the course of examining
the trunk of the car, the investigators discovered a small cluster of fibers that may have been human hair. These fibers were sent for further analysis.
That evening, officers conducted a test using three trained German shepherd search dogs to determine
whether Piest had been present in any of Gacy's vehicles. The dogs were allowed to examine each of
Gacy's vehicles, whereupon one dog approached Gacy's Oldsmobile and lay upon the passenger seat in what the dog's
handler informed investigators was a "death
reaction", indicating the body of Robert
Piest had been present in this vehicle.
That evening, Gacy invited two of the surveillance
detectives to a restaurant for a meal. In the early hours of December 18, he
invited the same officers into another restaurant where, over breakfast, he
talked of his business, his marriages and his activities as a registered clown.
At one point during this conversation, Gacy remarked to one of the two
surveillance detectives: "You know…
clowns can get away with murder."
Civil suit
By December 18, Gacy was beginning to show visible signs of
strain as a result of the constant surveillance: he was unshaven, looked tired,
appeared anxious and was drinking heavily. That afternoon, he drove to his
lawyers' office to prepare a $750,000 civil suit against the Des Plaines police, demanding that they
cease their surveillance. The same day, the serial number of the Nisson Pharmacy photo receipt found in
Gacy's kitchen was traced to 17-year-old Kim
Byers, a colleague of Piest at Nisson
Pharmacy, who admitted when contacted in person the following day that she
had worn the jacket and had placed the receipt in the parka pocket just before
she gave the parka to Piest as he left the store to talk with a contractor. This revelation contradicted Gacy's previous
statements that he had had no contact with Robert
Piest on the evening of December 11: the presence of the receipt indicated
that Gacy must have been in contact with Robert
Piest after the youth had left the Nisson
Pharmacy on December 11.
The same evening, Michael
Rossi was interviewed a second time: on this occasion, Rossi was more
cooperative, informing detectives that in the summer of 1977, Gacy had had him
spread ten bags of lime in the crawl space of the house.
On December 19, investigators began compiling evidence for a
second search warrant of Gacy's house. The same day, Gacy's lawyers filed the
civil suit against the Des Plaines
police. The hearing of the suit was scheduled for December 22. That afternoon,
Gacy invited two of the surveillance detectives inside his house. On this
occasion, as one officer distracted Gacy with a conversation, another officer
walked into Gacy's bedroom in an unsuccessful attempt to write down the serial
number of the Motorola TV set they
suspected belonged to John Szyc.
While flushing Gacy's toilet, this officer noticed a smell he suspected could
be that of rotting corpses emanating from a heating duct; the officers who
previously searched Gacy's house had failed to notice this, as on that occasion
the house had been cold.
Both David Cram
and Michael Rossi was interviewed
by investigators on December 20. Rossi had agreed to be interviewed in relation
to his possible links with John Szyc
as well as the disappearance of Robert
Piest. When questioned by Detective
Joseph R. Kozenczak as to where he believed Gacy had placed Piest's body,
Rossi replied: "In the crawl space;
he could have put him in the crawl space." A polygraph test conducted upon the youth
showed his responses to questions to be inconclusive; however, upon his
agreeing to a subsequent visual test in which a map of Cook County was divided into 12 grid sections numbered 1 to 12,
with Gacy's home marked in the fourth grid section, Kozenczak noted an extreme
response in Rossi's blood pressure when asked: "Is the body of Robert Piest buried in grid number 4?" Upon hearing this question, Rossi refused to
continue the polygraph questioning, although he did discuss further his digging
trenches in the crawl space and remarked upon Gacy's insistence that he not
deviate from where he was instructed to dig.
Cram himself informed investigators of Gacy's attempts to
rape him in 1976 and stated that after he and Gacy had returned to his home
after the December 13 search of his property, Gacy had turned pale upon noting
a clot of mud on his carpet which he suspected had come from his crawl space.
Cram then stated Gacy had grabbed a flashlight and immediately entered the
crawl space to look for evidence of digging. When asked whether he had been to
the crawl space, Cram replied he had been asked by Gacy to spread lime down
there and also dug trenches upon Gacy's behest with the explanation they were
for plumbing. Cram stated these trenches
were 2 feet (0.61 m) wide, 6 feet (1.8 m) long and 2 feet (0.61 m) deep—the
size of graves.
Verbal confession
On the evening of December 20, Gacy drove to his lawyers'
office in Park Ridge to attend a
pre-scheduled meeting he had arranged with them, ostensibly to discuss the
progress of his civil suit. Upon his arrival, Gacy appeared disheveled and
immediately asked for an alcoholic drink, whereupon Sam Amirante fetched a bottle of whiskey from his car. Upon his
return, Amirante asked Gacy what he had to discuss with them. Gacy picked up a
copy of the Daily Herald from
Amirante's desk; he pointed to a front-page article covering the disappearance
of Robert Piest and informed his
lawyers: "This boy is dead. He's in
a river."
Over the following hours, Gacy gave a rambling confession
that ran into the early hours of the following morning. He began by informing
Amirante and Stevens he had "been
the judge ... jury and executioner of many, many people", most of whom
he stated was buried in his crawl space and others in the Des Plaines River. Some victims he referred to by name; most he
dismissed as "male
prostitutes", "hustlers"
and "liars" to whom he gave
"the rope trick". On other
occasions, he stated he woke up to find "dead,
strangled kids" on his floor, with their hands cuffed behind their
back. In reference to Robert Piest, Gacy stated that as he
placed the tourniquet around his neck that Piest was "crying, scared".
As a result of the alcohol he had consumed, Gacy fell asleep
midway through his confession and Amirante immediately arranged a psychiatric
appointment for Gacy at 9 a.m. that morning. Upon awakening several hours
later, Gacy simply shook his head when informed by Amirante he had earlier
confessed to killing approximately 30 people, stating: "Well, I can't think about this right now. I've got things to
do." Ignoring his lawyers'
advice regarding his scheduled appointment, Gacy left their office to attend to
the needs of his business.
Gacy later recollected his memories of his final day of
freedom as being "hazy",
adding that he knew his arrest was inevitable and that, in his final hours of
freedom, he intended to visit his friends and say his final farewells. Upon leaving his lawyers' office, Gacy drove
to a Shell gas station where in the
course of filling his rental car, he handed a small bag of cannabis to the
attendant, a youth named Lance Jacobson.
Jacobson immediately handed the bag to the surveillance officers, adding that
Gacy had told him: "The end is
coming (for me). These guys are going to kill me." Gacy then drove to
the home of a fellow contractor, Ronald
Rhode. Inside Rhode's living room, Gacy hugged Rhode before bursting into
tears and saying: "I killed thirty
people, give or take a few." Gacy then left Rhode's home to meet with Michael Rossi and David Cram. As he drove along the expressway, the surveillance
officers noted he was holding a rosary to his chin as he prayed while driving.
After talking with Cram and Rossi at Cram's home, Gacy had
Cram drive him to a scheduled meeting with Leroy
Stevens. As he spoke with his lawyer, Cram informed the officers that Gacy
had earlier divulged to both himself and Rossi that the previous evening, he had
confessed to his lawyers his guilt in over thirty murders. Upon concluding his
meeting with his lawyer, Gacy had Cram drive him to Maryhill Cemetery, where his father was buried.
As Gacy drove to various locations that morning, police
outlined their formal draft of their second search warrant. The purpose of the
warrant was specifically to search for the body of Robert Piest in the crawl space. Upon hearing radioed reports from
the surveillance detectives that, in light of his erratic behavior, Gacy might
be about to commit suicide, police decided to arrest him upon a charge of
possession and distribution of marijuana in order to hold him in custody as the
formal request for a second search warrant was presented. At 4:30 on the
afternoon of December 21, the eve of the hearing of Gacy's civil suit, the
request for a second search warrant was granted by Judge Marvin J. Peters.
Armed with the signed search warrant, police and evidence
technicians quickly drove to Gacy's home. Upon their arrival, officers found
that Gacy had unplugged his sump pump and that the crawl space was flooded with
water; to clear the water they simply replaced the plug and waited for the
water to drain. After it had done so, an evidence technician named Daniel Genty entered the 28-by-38-foot
(8.5 m × 11.6 m) crawl space crawled to the southwest area and began digging.
Within minutes, he had uncovered putrefied flesh and a human arm bone. Genty
immediately shouted to the investigators that they could charge Gacy with
murder. Genty added the remark: "I think this place is full of
kids."
Arrest and confession
After being informed that the police had found human remains
in his crawl space and that he would now face murder charges, Gacy told
officers he wanted to "clear the
air", adding that he knew his arrest was inevitable since he had spent
the previous evening on the couch in his lawyers' office.
In the early hours of December 22, 1978, Gacy confessed to
police that since 1972, he had committed 25 to 30 murders, all of whom he
falsely claimed were of teenage male runaways or male prostitutes, whom he
typically abducted from Chicago's
Greyhound Bus station, from Bughouse
Square or simply off the streets. The victims were often grabbed by force
or conned into believing Gacy—often carrying a sheriff's badge and placing
spotlights on his black Oldsmobile—was
a policeman. Others were lured to his
house with either the promise of a job with his construction company or an
offer of money for sex.
Inside Gacy's house, the victims would be handcuffed or
otherwise bound, then sexually assaulted and tortured. To muffle his victims'
screams, Gacy often stuck cloth rags or items of the victim's own clothing in
their mouths. Some victims had been partly drowned in his bathtub before they
had been revived, enabling Gacy to continue his prolonged assault. Many of his victims had been strangled with a
tourniquet, which Gacy referred to as his "rope
trick"; occasionally, the victim had convulsed for an "hour or two" after the rope
trick before dying. With only two exceptions, all his victims had died between
3 a.m. and 6 a.m. When asked where he
drew the inspiration for the two-by-four found at his house in which he had
manacled many of his victims, Gacy stated he had been inspired to construct the
device from reading about the Houston
Mass Murders.
The victims were usually lured alone to his house, although
on approximately three occasions, Gacy had what he called "doubles"—occasions wherein he killed two victims on the
same evening. After death, the victims' bodies were would typically be stored
beneath his bed for up to 24 hours before burial in the crawl space, although
the bodies of some victims had been taken to his garage and embalmed prior to
their burial.
Most victims were buried in Gacy's crawl space, where he
periodically poured quicklime to hasten the decomposition of the bodies. In January 1979, he had planned to further
conceal the corpses by covering the entire crawl space with concrete. Gacy stated he had lost count of the number of
victims buried in his crawl space and had initially considered stowing bodies
in his attic before opting to dispose of his victims off the I-55 bridge into the Des Plaines River. Thus the final five victims—all killed in
1978—were disposed of in this manner, because his crawl space was full.
When specifically questioned about Robert Piest, Gacy confessed to strangling the youth at his house
on the evening of December 11 after luring him there, adding that he had been
interrupted by a phone call from a business colleague while doing so; he also
admitted to having slept alongside the youth's body that evening, before
disposing of the corpse in the Des
Plaines River the following evening. The reason he had arrived at the Des Plaines police station in a dirty and
the disheveled manner in the early hours of December 13 was that he had been in a
minor traffic accident after disposing of Piest's body, en route to his
appointment with Des Plaines
officers. In this accident, his vehicle had slid off an ice-covered road, and
he had unsuccessfully attempted to free the vehicle himself before the vehicle
had to be towed from its location. He
also confessed to police he had buried the body of John Butkovich in his garage. To assist officers in their search for the
victims buried in his house, Gacy drew a rough diagram of his basement upon a
phone message sheet to show where the bodies were buried.
Search for victims
Accompanied by police, Gacy returned to his house on
December 22 and showed police the location in his garage where he had buried
Butkovich's body. The police then drove to the spot on the I-55 Bridge from which he had thrown the body of Piest and four
other victims. Only four of the five victims Gacy claimed to have disposed of
in this way were recovered from the Des
Plaines River.
Between December 22 and 29, 1978, 27 bodies were recovered
from Gacy's property, 26 of which were found buried in his crawl space, with
one additional victim, John Butkovich,
being found buried beneath the concrete floor of his garage precisely where
Gacy had marked the youth's grave with a can of spray paint. Following a temporary postponement of the
excavations imposed in January 1979 because of a severe winter snowfall in Chicago, excavations of the property
resumed in March—despite Gacy's insistence to investigators that all the
victims' bodies buried upon his property had been found.
On March 9, the body of a 28th victim was found buried in a
pit close to a barbecue grill in the backyard of the property: the victim was
found wrapped within several plastic bags and wore a silver ring on the fourth
finger of his left hand, indicating the possibility he had been married. One week later, on March 16, the skeletal
remains of another victim were found buried beneath the joists of the dining
room floor, bringing the total number of
bodies exhumed at 8213 West Summerdale
Avenue to 29. In April 1979, Gacy's
vacant house was demolished.
Three additional bodies, which had been found in the nearby Des Plaines River between June and
December 1978, were also confirmed to have been victims of Gacy.
Several bodies unearthed at Gacy's property were found with
plastic bags over their heads or upper torsos. In addition, several of the bodies were found
with the ligature used to strangle them still knotted around their necks. In
other instances, cloth gags were found lodged deep down the victims' throats,
leading the Cook County medical
examiner to conclude that 12 victims buried beneath Gacy's property died not of
strangulation, but of asphyxiation. In
some cases, bodies were found with foreign objects such as prescription bottles
lodged into their pelvic region, the position of which indicated the items had
been thrust into the victims' anus. All
the victims discovered at 8213
Summerdale was in an advanced state of decomposition, and the medical
examiner chiefly relied upon dental records to facilitate the identification of
the remains.
Two victims were identified because of their known
connection to Gacy through PDM
Contractors; most identifications were facilitated with the assistance of
X-ray charts. These identifications were
also supported via personal artifacts being found at 8213 Summerdale: one victim, 19-year-old David Talsma, was identified via comparison of radiology records of
a healed fracture of the left scapula matching distress evident upon the 17th
skeleton recovered from Gacy's property; another youth, Timothy O'Rourke, was last heard mentioning that a contractor had
offered him a job. Of Gacy's identified
victims, the youngest was Samuel Dodd
Stapleton and Michael Marino,
both 14 years old; the oldest was Russell
Nelson, who was 21 years old. Six of the victims have never been identified.
On April 9, 1979, a decomposed body was discovered entangled
in exposed roots on the edge of the Des
Plaines River in Grundy County. The
body was identified via dental records as being that of Robert Piest. A subsequent autopsy revealed that three wads of "paper-like material" had been
shoved down his throat while he was alive, causing him to die of suffocation.
Trial
Gacy was brought to trial on February 6, 1980, charged with
33 murders. He was tried in Cook County, Illinois, before Judge Louis Garippo; the jury was
selected from Rockford because of
significant press coverage in Cook
County.
At the request of his defense counsel, Gacy spent over three
hundred hours in the year before his trial with the doctors at the Menard Correctional Center. He underwent
a variety of psychological tests before a panel of psychiatrists to determine
whether he was mentally competent to stand trial.
Gacy had attempted to convince the doctors that he suffered
from a multiple personality disorder. His lawyers opted to have Gacy plead not
guilty by reason of insanity to the charges against him, and produced several
psychiatric experts who had examined Gacy the previous year to testify to their
findings. Three psychiatric experts
appearing for the defense at Gacy's trial testified they found Gacy to be a
paranoid schizophrenic with a multiple personality disorder.
The prosecutors presented a case that indicated Gacy was
sane and fully in control of his actions. To support this contention, they produced
several witnesses to testify to the premeditation of Gacy's actions and the
efforts he went to in order to escape detection. Those doctors refuted the
defense doctors' claims of multiple personality and insanity. Two witnesses who
testified were PDM employees, who
confessed Gacy had made them dig trenches in his crawl space. One of these
employees, David Cram, testified
that in August 1977, Gacy had marked a location in the crawl space with sticks
and told him to dig a drainage trench.
Immediately after Cram had completed his testimony, Michael Rossi himself testified for the
state. When asked where he had dug in the crawl space, Rossi turned to a
diagram of Gacy's home on display in the courtroom. This diagram showed where
the bodies were found in the crawl space and elsewhere on the property. Rossi
pointed to the location of the remains of an unidentified victim known as "Body 13". Rossi stated he had not dug any other
trenches, but—at Gacy's request—had supervised other PDM employees digging trenches in the crawl space.
Both Rossi and Cram also testified that Gacy periodically
looked into the crawl space to ensure they and other employees ordered to dig
trenches in the crawl space did not deviate from the precise locations he had
marked. Gacy had testified after his
arrest that he had only dug five of the victims' graves in his crawl space and
had his employees (including Gregory
Godzik) dig the remaining trenches so that he would "have graves available".
On February 18, Dr.
Robert Stein, the Cook County
medical examiner appointed to supervise the exhumation of the victims' bodies
from Gacy's home, testified as to how he and his colleagues had conducted the
recovery of the remains. Stein testified that the excavation was conducted in
an "archeological fashion",
adding that all the bodies recovered were "markedly
decomposed, putrefied, skeletalized remains". In relation to the cause of death of each
victim upon which he had later performed an autopsy, Stein stated he had
concluded that thirteen victims had died of asphyxiation; six had died of
ligature strangulation and one victim of multiple stab wounds to the chest. Stein testified that the cause of death in ten
cases could not be determined, although all were ruled as homicides.
Upon cross-examination, Gacy's defense team attempted to
raise the possibility that all 33 murders were accidental erotic asphyxia
deaths: Dr. Stein countered this assertion by stating that this claim was
highly improbable.
Three days after the testimony of Dr. Robert Stein, Jeffrey
Rignall testified on behalf of the prosecution, recounting the abuse and
torture he had endured at Gacy's hands in March 1978. Rignall repeatedly wept
as he recounted his ordeal. In response to questioning relating to whether Gacy
appreciated the criminality of his actions, Rignall stated his belief that Gacy
was unable to conform his actions to the conduct of law because of the "beastly and animalistic ways he
attacked me". Upon specific
cross-examination relating to the torture he had endured, Rignall vomited
before he was excused from further testimony.
On February 29, one of the youths Gacy had sexually
assaulted in 1967, Donald Voorhees,
testified to his ordeal at Gacy's hands, and that Gacy had subsequently paid
another youth to beat him and spray Mace in his face so he would not testify
against him. The youth felt unable to
testify, but did briefly attempt to do so, before being asked to step down.
Robert Donnelly
testified the week after Voorhees, recounting his ordeal at Gacy's hands in
December 1977. Donnelly was visibly distressed as he recollected the abuse he
endured at Gacy's hands and came close to breaking down on several occasions.
As Donnelly testified, Gacy repeatedly laughed at him, but Donnelly finished
his testimony. One of Gacy's defense attorneys, Robert Motta, during Donnelly's cross-examination, attempted to
discredit his testimony, but Donnelly did not waver from his testimony of what
had occurred.
During the fifth week of the trial, Gacy wrote a personal
letter to Judge Garippo requesting a mistrial on a number of bases, including
that he did not approve his lawyers' insanity plea approach; that his lawyers
had not allowed him to take the witness stand (as he had desired to do); that
his defense had not called enough witnesses, and that the police were lying
about statements he had purportedly made to detectives after his arrest and
that, in any event, the statements were "self-serving"
for use by the prosecution. Judge
Garippo addressed Gacy's letter by informing him that under the law he had the
choice as to whether he wished to testify, and he was free to indicate as much
to the judge, if he wished to do so.
No comments:
Post a Comment