The Motu Proprio Vos
estis lux mundi
On May 9, 2019, Pope Francis issued the Motu Proprio Vos
estis lux mundi requiring both clerics
and religious brothers and sisters, including Bishops, throughout the world to
report sex abuse cases and sex abuse cover-ups by their superiors. Under the new Motu Proprio, all Catholic
dioceses throughout the world are required to establish stable mechanisms or
systems through which people may submit reports of abuse or its cover-up by
June 2020. All metropolitan Archdioceses
are also required to send reports to the Holy See on the progress of the
investigation, whether in their Archdiocese or suffragan dioceses, every 30
days and to complete the investigation within 90 days unless granted an
extension.[319] The law is effective for a 3-year experimental period with a
vacatio legis of 1 June 2019. According to Canon law professor Kurt Martens:
This new law is without
a doubt a rare gift to the entire church and sets, along with the companion
Vatican law providing for jail time for any public official of the Vatican who
fails to report abuse, an unmistakable new course. The painful, sometimes
bitter, experience of the church in the United States and the voices of the
faithful worldwide have helped bring about a change in attitude and a change in
law. There is no turning back now, and the tone has been set for the future.
Criticisms of church responses:
While the church in the United States claims to have
addressed the issue, some disagree. Mark Honigsbaum of The Guardian wrote in
2006 that, "despite the National Review Board's own estimates that there
have been some 5,000 abusive priests in the US, to date 150 have been
successfully prosecuted." Some critics of the church, such as Patrick
Wall, attribute this to a lack of cooperation from the church. In California,
for example, the archdiocese has sought to block the disclosure of confidential
counseling records on two priests, arguing that such action would violate their
First Amendment right on religious protection. Paul Lakeland claims Church leaders who
enabled abuse were too frequently careless about their own accountability and
the accountability of perpetrators.
In 2010, the BBC reported that the latest research by
experts indicate that Catholic priests may be no more likely than others to
abuse. However, a major cause of the scandal was the cover-ups and other
alleged shortcomings in the way the church hierarchy have dealt with the
abuses. Particularly, the actions of
Catholic bishops in responding to allegations of clerical abuse were harshly
criticized.
In September 2010, Pope Benedict XVI lamented that the Roman
Catholic Church had not been vigilant enough or quick enough in responding to
the problem of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy. Pope Benedict laicized 400 priests for abuses
in two years of his papacy. A
representative of Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP), a group
representing abuse victims, criticized the pope's remarks as
"disingenuous" because, in her opinion, the church had in fact been
"prompt and vigilant" in concealing the scandal. After Benedict's resignation in 2013, he was
criticized by SNAP for allegedly protecting the church's reputation "over
the safety of children." Representatives from the Center for
Constitutional Rights (at the time engaged in an International Criminal Court
case against Pope Benedict in which they were acting for SNAP), alleged that
Pope Benedict had been directly involved in covering up some of the crimes.
For non-removal
The Catholic hierarchy has been criticized for not acting
more quickly and decisively to remove, laicize and report priests accused of
sexual misconduct. Cardinal Roger Mahony of the Archdiocese of Los Angeles,
said: "We have said repeatedly that ... our understanding of this problem
and the way it's dealt with today evolved, and that in those years ago, decades
ago, people didn't realize how serious this was, and so, rather than pulling
people out of ministry directly and fully, they were moved."
One early opponent of the treatment of sexually abusive
priests was Father Gerald Fitzgerald, the founder of The Congregation of the
Servants of the Paraclete. Although Fitzgerald started the Servants of the
Paraclete to assist priests who were struggling with alcohol and substance
abuse problems, he soon began receiving priests who had sexually abused minors.
Initially, Fitzgerald attempted to treat such priests using the same spiritual
methods that he used with his other "guests". However, as he grew
convinced of the futility of treating sexually abusive priests, Fitzgerald came
to oppose vehemently the return of sexual abusers to duties as parish priests.
He wrote regularly to bishops in the United States and to Vatican officials,
including the pope, of his opinion that many sexual abusers in the priesthood
could not be cured and should be laicizied immediately.
Eventually, Fitzgerald lost control of the Servants of the
Paraclete. The center began to employ medical and psychological professionals
who added psychiatry and medical treatment to the spiritual regimen of
treatment favored by Fitzgerald. Fitzgerald continued to oppose these
modifications to his treatment regimen until his death in 1969.
Bishop Manuel D. Moreno of Tucson, Arizona, United States
repeatedly attempted to have two local abusive priests laicized and
disciplined, pleading unsuccessfully in a letter of April 1997 with Cardinal
Joseph Ratzinger as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith to
have one laicized; he was first suspended in 1990 and convicted by the church
in 1997 of five crimes, including sexual solicitation in the confessional. The
two were finally laicized in 2004.[328] Bishop Moreno had been strongly
criticized for failing to take action until details of his efforts became
public.
In a The New York Times article, Bishop Blase J. Cupich,
chairman of the United States Bishops Committee for the Protection of Children
and Young People, is quoted explaining why Father Fitzgerald's advice
"went largely unheeded for 50 years": First, "cases of sexually abusive
priests were considered to be rare." Second, Father Fitzgerald's,
"views, by and large, were considered bizarre with regard to not treating
people medically, but only spiritually, and also segregating a whole population
with sexual problems on a deserted island." And finally, "There was
mounting evidence in the world of psychology that indicated that when medical
treatment is given, these people can, in fact, go back to ministry." This
was a view which Cupich characterized as one that "the bishops came to
regret."
In 2010 several secular and liberal Catholics were calling
for Pope Benedict XVI's resignation, citing the actions of then Cardinal
Ratzinger's blocking of efforts to remove a priest convicted of child abuse. The pope did eventually resign in 2013,
although he said that he did so because of his declining health.
In 2012, Monsignor William Lynn became the first United
States church official to be convicted of child endangerment because of his
part in covering up child sex abuse allegations by clergy. Lynn was responsible
for making recommendations as to the assignment of clergy in the Archdiocese of
Philadelphia. He was found guilty of one count of endangering the welfare of a
child. On 24 July 2012, Lynn was
sentenced to three to six years in prison.
No comments:
Post a Comment