The North Head
Quarantine Station is a heritage-listed former quarantine station and
associated buildings that are now a tourist attraction at North Head Scenic
Drive, on the north side of Sydney Harbor at North Head, near Manly, in the
Northern Beaches Council local government area of New South Wales, Australia.
It is also known as North Head Quarantine Station & Reserve and Quarantine
Station & Reserve. The property is owned by the Office of Environment and
Heritage, an agency of the Government of New South Wales. The buildings and
site were added to the New South Wales State Heritage Register on 2 April 1999.
The entire 277-hectare (680-acre) North Head site, including the Quarantine
Station and associated buildings and facilities, was added to the Australian
National Heritage List on 12 May 2006, and now forms part of the Sydney Harbour
National Park.
The complex operated as a quarantine station from 14 August
1832 to 29 February 1984. The concept behind its establishment was that, as an
island-nation, the Colony of New South Wales, as it then was, was susceptible
to ship-borne disease. Those who might have an infectious disease would be kept
in quarantine until it was considered safe to release them. The isolation and
strategic role of North Head was recognised in 1828 when the first vessel, the
Bussorah Merchant, was quarantined at Spring Cove. The importance and future
role of North Head was reinforced by Governor Darling's Quarantine Act of 1832,
which set aside the whole of North Head for quarantine purposes in response to
the 1829–51 cholera pandemic in Europe.
The station is now home to a hotel, conference centre, and
restaurant complex known as Q Station, and remains part of the Sydney Harbour
National Park. One of the early quarantine officers was Dr James Stuart, a keen
naturalist and painter. For many years Percy Nolan, an alderman and mayor of
Manly, pushed for the removal of the Quarantine Station from Manly and called
for its use as public open space. Over sixty years later, this far-sighted proposal
became a reality.
In the 1960s and 70s, the officer then in charge of the
Quarantine Station, Herb Lavaring BEM (1917–1998), took it upon himself to
preserve and compile a museum of artifacts and other items of note and
significance to the station's operations, including domestic implements,
medical instruments, and hand tools for tasks ranging from blacksmithing to
building construction. Lavaring collected these materials over the period
1963–1975 and also commenced restoration work on the diverse range of rock
carvings and headstones from the major burial grounds. The items collected by
Lavaring were preserved, and many have since found their way into state and
federal collections, including the National Museum in Canberra, where a
muzzle-loading rifle and a set of manacles are preserved (the latter being used
to ensure that no one left the station without medical clearance).
One of the most historic features of the quarantine station
is the series of engravings along the escarpment adjacent to the jetty. The
carvings were executed by people staying at the quarantine station, and cover
an extensive period that stretched from the early nineteenth century to the
mid-twentieth century. Some were executed by stonemasons and sculptors and show
a high degree of skill. More carvings are located at the rock formation known
as Old Man's Hat.
History
The Quarantine Station was established primarily to regulate
the risk of disease importation through the migration of free and convict
Europeans, and the arrival of merchant shipping. There was always a close link
between the requirement for quarantine and the ebb and flow of sea-borne
immigration; and the growth of the Quarantine Station from the 1830s parallels
the changes in immigration policy and practice. The other major influence was
the imperative to limit disruption to the increasingly commercially-sensitive
shipping industry.
As the dominant headland of the harbor, North Head was of
importance in navigation from the time of the First Fleet. By 1809 navigational
plans were showing an obelisk, located in what was to become the Quarantine
Station precinct, presumed to have been used as a channel marker for vessels
negotiating the Sow and Pigs Reef. A 10-metre-high (33 ft) obelisk still exists
on this site, which may be the original marker, making it potentially one of
the oldest European structures on Sydney Harbor.
Up until the 1830s, the majority of ships requiring
quarantine were convict transports, and being under government contract, the
somewhat informal proclamation of quarantine by the Governor of the day was
easy to enforce. One reason for the introduction of formal statutory regulation
for quarantine in NSW in 1832 was the increasing rate of free immigrant vessels
entering port. In 1831 thirty four immigrant ships had arrived, and this
increased to 63 in 1832. The captains of these free vessels were less ready to
comply with such informal and ad hoc processes, thus a legislated requirement
for all ships entering port to be screened for disease, and quarantined if
necessary, was needed.
Another problem with the changing nature of the shipping
entering Sydney was the increasing time constraints placed on the captains of
commercial vessels, necessitating rapid turn-around in port-time wasted in
port, and in quarantine, was income lost. The convict ships, under government
contract, could be isolated for the period of quarantine with little added
expense, but free commercial carriers sought demurrage from government for any
delays it imposed. In part, the disruption to shipping caused by traditional
quarantine practices led to the progressive move away from detention-based
quarantine in Britain through the middle years of the 19th century.
Following passage of
the Quarantine Act, 1832
When the 1832 Quarantine Act was passed in NSW, Viscount
Goderich, British Secretary of State for War and Colonies, warned that
quarantine was prejudicial to the trade of the kingdom and that the colony
should be aware of the importance of "not
aggravating by unnecessary restrictions the embarrassment inseparable from a
strict quarantine on British Vessels".
The initial quarantine practice of housing the sick on board
the vessel in which they arrived, was dispensed with after the experience with
the long detention of the Lady Macnaghten in 1837, and the subsequent heavy
demurrage claimed for that delay. After that time the sick were removed from
their ship and housed ashore, while the ship was fumigated and scoured for
return to the owner with the minimum delay. A consequence of this decision was
the construction of permanent accommodation and stores buildings at the Quarantine
Station at North Head.
The alarming experiences of quarantine in 1837 and 1838
prompted a review in the colony of the organisation and conditions aboard
immigrant ships. The final report, arising as a NSW initiative, pricked the
sensitivities of the British emigration officials, but nevertheless had
positive outcomes. The review indicated that there was insufficient checking of
the health of the emigrants before boarding; there was insufficient concern
with diet during the voyage, especially for the needs of children; and that the
formula of three children equaling one adult when allocating food and berth
space aboard required reconsideration, as it led to excessive number of
children in cramped spaces, with inadequate food. Finally it indicated that the
surgeon-superintendent aboard ship required more authority to regulate and
promote good health and good order among the emigrants.
The subsequent reorganization of the system resulted in
interviews and medical checks on would-be emigrants before embarking them;
vaccination for smallpox of all emigrants; the signing of undertakings to
follow the directions of the surgeon-superintendent on voyage and better
definition of his role and powers; improvements in diet and hospital
accommodation aboard; and moves to prevent overcrowding.
The rate of mortality improved dramatically. In 1840 the
death rate for children fell from one in ten to one in seventeen, and that for
adults also fell. With the improved conditions the rate of quarantine
declaration of immigrant ships also fell in 1840, from three ships out of 43 in
1839 to one out of 40 in 1840.
Immigration was reduced from 1842 due to the economic
recession in the colony, as the decline in land sales had reduced the pool of
funds earmarked to support the migration scheme. Immigration was at a
standstill from 1842 until 1848, and only one ship was quarantined in this
period. The resumption of immigration in 1847-48 led to a review of the
adequacy of the Quarantine Station, but no real increase in accommodation
resulted.
The arrival of the Beejapore in 1853, with over one thousand
passengers, at a time when the Quarantine Station could accommodate 150
persons, triggered a new building phase. As a temporary measure, the hulk
Harmony was purchased and moored in Spring Cove as a hospital ship. The
Beejapore was an experiment in trying to reduce migration costs by using
two-deck vessels, and the outcome was judged not to be a success. Fifty-five
people died during the voyage, and a further sixty two died at the Quarantine
Station, from the illnesses of measles, scarlet fever and typhus fever. The majority
of the passengers and crew had to be housed in tents. The biggest impetus for
change came not so much from a concern about poor housing, but rather a concern
for the morals of the married women and the "200
single women let loose in the bush" that represented the undeveloped
station at that time. The resulting changes to the station, besides the use of
the hospital ship, included the construction of a barracks for the single women
in the former Sick Ground, surrounded by a double fence with a sentry stationed
between them, to prevent communication with the women. Two new buildings were
built in the Healthy Ground, each to house sixty people, with verandahs for
dining. The original burial ground was levelled and the grave stones removed to
the new burial ground, thus further removing the burials from the view of the
Healthy Ground. Eight quarters were also built for the Superintendent.
1860s to 1890s
The downturn in immigration during the economically stagnant
period of the 1860s, triggered by the colonial government cancelling the
regulations to provide assisted passage to migrants in 1860, limited the use of
the Quarantine Station, and the willingness of the government to spend money on
its upkeep. As a result of this downturn between 1860 and 1879 only 138
immigrant vessels arrived [compared with 410 between 1840 and 1859], and of
these 33 required cleansing at the Quarantine Station, but few required their
passengers to be landed and accommodated. In the same period 29 merchant or
naval vessels were quarantined, but again mainly for the cleansing of the ship
rather than the landing of diseased crews.
The run-down Quarantine Station had become unsuitable for
passenger quarantine, and particularly for first and second class passenger
accommodation, by the time the Hero was in need of quarantine for smallpox in
1872. The passengers were kept aboard the ship, because the station could not
adequately house them. The inadequacy was further publicized during the
quarantine of the Baroda in 1873, when first class passengers had to do their
own washing. Well-connected passengers ensured that government attention was focused
on the shortcomings of the Station accommodation. As result, a new group of
First Class accommodation buildings were built in the Healthy Ground.
From 1881 to 1894, a smallpox hospital ship, Faraway, was
anchored off the Quarantine Station, and before that at Sirius Cove. The ship
hulk had been converted to a hospital ship by the beginning of 1877, and was
already in use during January 1877. Largely as a result of poor outcomes during
the 1881-1882 smallpox epidemics, in 1884, Faraway was upgraded, at Mort's
Dock, to a more suitable floating hospital with two wards and 100 beds. The
ship was thereafter officially known as the Floating Quarantine Hospital.
As steam navigation became more common, the costs of delays
to shipping schedules by quarantine became more pressing. By the 1870s the
detention of a steamer could cost from £20 to £300 per day, and shipping agents
and owners could not see why Australia was not following Britain's lead in
abandoning quarantine regulations. In response the Assistant Health Officer was
based at Watson's Bay from 1882, to reduce delays in inspection. The Shipping
Owner's Association also requested the provision of Asiatic accommodation at
the Quarantine Station, a better supply of water there, the supply of a steam
launch to take supplies to the quarantined ships, and printed instructions for
Captains of quarantined vessels.11 The issue of abandoning quarantine was
raised again in 1882, and in his report on the issue the new Health Officer,
C.H. Mackellar, dismissed the suggestion and suggested a federation of
quarantine efforts, to detect and cleanse infected ships as they reached the
continent at places such as Thursday Island and Albany, not just as they
reached Sydney. Mackellar also recommended the upgrade of the Station, with the
introduction of a light tram, a new reservoir, improved cleansing facilities at
the wharf, a better hospital, new accommodation, and picket fences to delineate
zones in the quarantine. Most of these suggestions were acted on, and some of
the buildings survive.
1900s to date
When the Commonwealth took over responsibility for the
Quarantine Service after 1909, and particularly after the creation of the
Department of Health in 1921, the nature of quarantine changed for merchant
shipping. The Commonwealth drew together the Quarantine Stations in the various
states, and tried to diversify the operations so that some ships were
intercepted at out-lying ports before they reached Sydney. Albany, Melbourne
and Thursday Island, in particular played a major role in this new pattern of
nationwide quarantine.
The growth of the other states also meant that shipping was
more evenly distributed in terms of destination than had been the case in the
nineteenth century. In the period 1901 to 1940, Sydney and Melbourne had
roughly similar numbers of assisted immigrants (134,864 and 115,988
respectively), and the other States had, in combination, more immigrants than
either Sydney or Melbourne, totalling 174,526. By 1958 there were 39 "first ports of entry" into
Australia. Thirty-two sea ports had staff capable of carrying out quarantine
inspections, ten ports were "landing places" for air entry; major
quarantine stations with accommodation were established at five ports, and
there were three minor quarantine stations at other Ports.
The impact of improved medical science, immunization, and
quarantine procedures in the twentieth century is perhaps shown most
dramatically by the fact that though the post-WWII immigration was vastly more
than had gone before, the number of ships or aeroplanes quarantined plummeted
proportionately. Sydney received nearly 700,000 assisted immigrants between
1946 and 1980, or nearly double the number it had received between 1831 and
1940, yet only four ships was quarantined in that period and at least one of
those was a tanker.
In all, between 1828 and 1984 at least 580 vessels were
quarantined at the Quarantine Station. More than 13,000 people were quarantined
at the station of who an estimated 572 died and were buried there.
Description
European/Asian
cultural heritage
North Head is situated at the entrance to Sydney Harbour. It
is a huge sandstone bluff rising 80 meters (260 ft) above sea level. At the
time of European settlement North Head was linked to the mainland by only a
narrow sand spit that separated the harbor from the sea. Early depictions of
North Head show the dramatic upheaval of the land form that sloped from the
high cliffs on the eastern seaboard back to the protected waters of the harbor
to the west. Today North Head appears as a natural extension of the Manly
peninsula due to the filling of medium rise building development on the
low-lying land of the present-day site of Manly and the mature vegetation
through that urban development. The Quarantine Station is situated on the
western side of North Head, on the natural amphitheatre of land centered on
Quarantine beach. The site was originally designated as all the land with a 500-meter
(1,600 ft) radius of the beach. The area is fringed by a continuous tract of
bushland on the north, south and eastern sides, and by the harbor on the
western side.
The curtilage for this Conservation Management Plan is the
western side of North Head, which has the Quarantine Station as its core. In
order to allow description and analysis of this study curtilage, five precincts
have been delineated within the study curtilage as follows:
The Quarantine Station
Precinct;
The Park Hill
Precinct;
The Spring Cove
Precinct;
The Quarantine [South]
Precinct; and
The Marine Precinct.
In addition, where Quarantine Station-related sites occur
beyond the briefed study area (such as within the Department of Defence-owned
property), these sites are detailed following the "precinctual" discussion. Each of these precincts and
related Quarantine Station sites are examined below.
Within the physical overview of the buildings and site
elements of the various precincts, the "description
fields" have been used, as appropriate.
Historical
archaeology sites
As a preamble to the precinct-specific overview, summary
statements that relate to the historical inscriptions, the historical
archaeology sites, and cultural landscape features for the study area have been
informed by the 1985 and 1992 Conservation Plans 1 and 2, and by NPWS
publications and other reports.
The historical
inscriptions
Quarantine internees commenced a tradition of making
inscriptions, including poems, initials, memorials and drawings, in the 1830s.
This continued throughout the life of the Quarantine Station. Nineteenth and
early twentieth century examples include engraved and painted inscriptions on
soft sandstone faces, structures and slate storm-water drain covers. Eight
hundred and fifty four examples have been recorded, though at least 1,000 other
examples exist.
The inscriptions commemorate quarantine events, ships and
people from the ships and deceased internees. They are located throughout the
place with concentrations around the Wharf Precinct and The Old Man’s Hat.
English and other European, Asian and Arabic languages were used. The most
recent inscriptions are a series of written examples on internal walls of
Building A20, deriving from its use as a detention centre for illegal
immigrants. Most of these appear to have been written by people from the
Pacific Islands, some in islander languages, many being laments on their
authors' detention or abuses directed at their detainers.
Most of the inscriptions are on quarried or natural
sandstone surfaces. A few occur on cement or plaster surfaces and several on built
elements such as brick walls, drain covers and the Cannae Point flagstaff. Some
have been re-worked in the past or are highlighted by paint. A large percentage
of the inscriptions are in good condition, easily located and readily legible.
Aspect, topography and environmental agents [sun, wind, and rain] affect the
condition of inscriptions but the major factor is the quality of stone, i.e.
the softer less silicified the sandstone the faster it deteriorates.
Seeping ground water, lichen, moss, wind and vegetation
abrasion and visitor contact are additional agents of deterioration. The latter
is now minimized through a policy of controlled access. The inscriptions in
Building A20 have a life limited to that of the paintwork and plaster render on
internal walls. A preliminary analysis of European rock inscriptions was
completed in 1983, and an interim report on the conservation of rock
inscriptions at the Quarantine Station was completed in March 1999, as part of
a joint project between the NPWS, Sydney, North Sub-District and the NPWS
Cultural Heritage Services Division.
The recommendations of the 1983 analysis were:
That the engravings at The Old Man’s Hat be recorded by a
similar program (such as that at the Quarantine Station core precinct) in order
to complete the record of the resource;
That, it funds become available, an indexing system of the
inscriptions be devised for the complete resource; and
That further research is carried out to identify whether
similar engravings have been located at other Quarantine facilities as a means
of assessing the National Heritage value of this material.
The 1999 Interim Report provided specific conservation
recommendations for the Wharf Area and The Old Man’s Hat inscriptions, and
general conservation management recommendations for visitor management and
monitoring. These recommendations are included as recommendations of this Plan.
The inscriptions are valuable and unusual graphic
illustrations of historical incidents and social patterns of Quarantine Station
history. They provide a very tangible and "human"
link with the past for present generations and are a valuable historical and
genealogical resource. Their research potential is enormous. The inscriptions
record a variety of information which cannot be obtained from any other source,
especially the feelings of non-English speaking migrants.
Historical
archaeological sites
The 1998 North Head Quarantine Station Conservation Plan
archaeological survey forms the current basis of assessment of areas within the
active Quarantine Station area. That report diagrammatically indicated the
historical archaeological sites and structures within or adjacent the North
Head Quarantine Station core precinct.
The 1991 North Head archaeological site survey forms the
basis of the assessment of areas outside the active Quarantine Station area.
That report indicated the following historical archaeological sites and
structures within or adjacent the North Head Quarantine Station study area:
The sandstone boundary
wall leading from the North Head Road to Collins Beach;
The sandstone boundary
wall south-east of the Quarantine Station (Site No. L10);
The Australian
Institute of Police Management, incorporating parts of the venereal diseases
hospital, the Second and Third Quarantine Cemeteries (Sites L1 and VA1); and
The Old Man’s Hat
inscription area; and the Quarantine Head gun emplacement.
All of these sites and structures are related to the history
of the Quarantine Station, and are significant physical evidence of the
development and contraction of quarantine functions over time. However, the
vast majority of buildings and archaeological sites are located within the zone
of most intensive quarantine activity, which is more or less contiguous with
the current NPWS managed area of the Quarantine Station. The NPWS has carried
out a number of historical archaeological surveys of areas of the Quarantine
Station itself, though there has as yet been no systematic survey of the entire
study area. These surveys have identified a large number of former building
sites and other features, and have indicated where as yet unlocated building
sites might be located. The site numbers beginning with "P" relate to "Potential
Sites". Forty-eight such sites had been identified by 1992. Because
the Quarantine Station has experienced over 150 years of quarantine activity,
there is a layering of evidence on and in the ground that reflects the slow
growth of the Station, the major development and redevelopment programs, and
the subsequent removals and constructions. This evidence exists as independent
evidence, though it is also complementary to the documentary evidence, and in
large part cannot be interpreted without reference to the latter. Because the
land-use over this period has been solely devoted to quarantine, the evidence
is, on the whole, only impacted by later quarantine activity, so the
understanding of both the creation and the destruction of the former buildings
and landscape elements contributes to the story of quarantine. Because in many
cases current building a relocated on the same sites as earlier building, and
as many of the surviving buildings have a long history of their own, all
sub-floor deposits are considered to have archaeological potential. The changes
over time reflected by the surviving buildings and features and the
archaeological sites reflect various aspects of the history of quarantine, public
health and society as a whole. The stories able to be illuminated by the
physical evidence include, among many others: the Aboriginal occupation of
North Head; the changing attitudes to quarantine and its administration; the
developing medical and epidemiological knowledge; the development of
Australia's immigration policies, and the experience of individuals and groups
within that history; the changing attitudes to class and race; the iconography
used by inmates to memorialize their experience, in the 1,000 plus
inscriptions, memorials and gravestones, and Australia's experience of war,
both in the diseases contracted by the military personnel buried in the
Quarantine Station cemeteries, and in the direct defense of Sydney. An unusual
aspect of the collection of historical archaeological evidence at the
Quarantine Station is that it all contributes to the understanding of this one
theme of quarantine as well as to associated broader themes, and a large amount
of evidence appears to have survived. This vests the archaeological sites with
a very high research potential for ongoing study of this important aspect of
Australian history. In addition to the archaeological potential of buildings
which have been demolished, the Quarantine Station buildings also offer the
opportunity to research the archaeology of standing structures. As a tightly
dated and well-documented group of buildings they have potential to provide
information on changes in domestic living arrangements over the past 150 years.
Since 1992 a number of the potential sites have been
confirmed by the location of above-ground evidence or the identification of
evidence during works. A systematic survey and recording program is required
both within and outside of the Planning Area to identify the complete
historical archaeological resource. This comprehensive survey is required as
much of the archaeological resource of the Quarantine Station is confined to
the thin vegetated surface and the poorly consolidated sandy soils beneath. The
fragility of the sites makes them prone to disturbance from excessive foot or
vehicle traffic, erosion and animal burrowing. A preliminary Archaeological
Management Plan has been prepared by the NPWS to accompany this Conservation
Management Plan; and the policy recommendations of that Plan have been
incorporated into this Conservation Management Plan.
The Quarantine
Station cultural landscape
The landscape of the Quarantine Station core precinct can be
properly described as a cultural landscape. It is a landscape heavily impacted
by human activity, even the "natural"
bushland areas are humanly modified; and the most obvious elements in the
landscape are the various layers of human clearing and construction, amid large
areas of bushland and interspersed with bush patches.
The main developed area consists of the Quarantine Station
itself. This has three main groups of buildings: the wharf and foreshore
buildings at Quarantine Beach, the hospital group, and the buildings on the
upper grassy slopes, with grassy cleared areas around these groups, delineated
by bushland remnants and regrowth. This creates a semi-rural, village-like
atmosphere which is uncommon in the otherwise closely developed Sydney
metropolitan area. The cultural landscape has heritage values in its own right,
as a document demonstrating the planning and construction of the station over
its entire life. The landscape also has a strong interpretative value.
The isolation of the Station, the long views out to other
parts of the harbor, the contrast between manicured grassy areas and
surrounding bush, which was alien to most of the inmates, and the strict
classification of occupation areas within the Station, combine to trigger the
historical imagination and allow the visitor to empathize with those
quarantined here.
The landscape is also visually important not only to
visitors to the Quarantine Station but also to viewers from other headlands,
suburbs or on the harbor. Many distinctive or prominent landscape elements
contribute to the multiple layering of human experience on the landscape.
A strong element in the cultural landscape is the conscious
and enforced "classification"
of the land, based on health issues, class and race. This includes the
isolation of the hospital, seen but not approached from many parts of the
Station; the wharf and "disinfection" area, which stood as a barrier
between the inmates and the main line of escape, and the administration area,
which "guarded" the land
route out; the lateral separation of the first, second and third class
passengers, with the administration area interposed between third class and the
rest, imposing class distinctions in the landscape; and the lateral and
elevational separation of the Asian accommodation, away from first and second
class, and below third class, imposing a racial layer on top of the class one.
The following discussion of the Quarantine Station cultural landscape refers
specifically to the cultural landscape elements which provide the meaning and
understanding of how these landscapes worked historically. These elements
include the Quarantine Station cemeteries; monuments; fences and walls;
boundary markers and walls; obelisks and cairns; and of course tracks, paths
and roads.
No comments:
Post a Comment