The Open Conspiracy
In his 1928 book, The Open Conspiracy British writer and
futurist H. G. Wells promoted cosmopolitanism and offered blueprints for a
world revolution and world brain to establish a technocratic world state and
planned economy. Wells warned, however, in his 1940 book The New World Order
that:
... when the struggle
seems to be drifting definitely towards a world social democracy, there may
still be very great delays and disappointments before it becomes an efficient
and beneficent world system. Countless people ... will hate the new world
order, be rendered unhappy by the frustration of their passions and ambitions
through its advent, and will die protesting against it. When we attempt to
evaluate its promise, we have to bear in mind the distress of a generation or
so of malcontents, many of them quite gallant and graceful-looking people.
Wells's books gave a second meaning to
the term "new world order",
which would only be used by state socialist supporters and anti-communist opponents
for generations to come. However, despite the popularity and notoriety of his
ideas, Wells failed to exert a deeper and more lasting influence because he was
unable to concentrate his energies on a direct appeal to intelligentsias who
would, ultimately, have to coordinate the Wellsian new world order.
New Age
British neo-Theosophical occultist Alice Bailey, one of the
founders of the so-called New Age movement, prophesied in 1940 the eventual
victory of the Allies of World War II over the Axis powers (which occurred in
1945) and the establishment by the Allies of a political and religious New
World Order. She saw a federal world government as the culmination of Wells'
Open Conspiracy but favorably argued that it would be synarchist because it was
guided by the Masters of the Ancient Wisdom, intent on preparing humanity for
the mystical second coming of Christ, and the dawning of the Age of Aquarius.
According to Bailey, a group of ascended masters called the Great White
Brotherhood works on the "inner
planes" to oversee the transition to the New World Order but, for now,
the members of this Spiritual Hierarchy are only known to a few occult
scientists, with whom they communicate telepathically, but as the need for
their personal involvement in the plan increases, there will be an
"Externalization of the Hierarchy" and everyone will know of their
presence on Earth.
Bailey's writings, along with American writer Marilyn
Ferguson's 1980 book The Aquarian Conspiracy, contributed to conspiracy
theorists of the Christian right viewing the New Age movement as the "false religion" that would
supersede Christianity in a New World Order. Skeptics argue that the term "New Age movement" is a
misnomer, generally used by conspiracy theorists as a catch-all rubric for any
new religious movement that is not fundamentalist Christian. By this logic,
anything that is not Christian is by definition actively and willfully anti-Christian.
Paradoxically, since the first decade of the 21st century,
New World Order conspiracism is increasingly being embraced and propagandized
by New Age occultists, who are people bored by rationalism and drawn to
stigmatized knowledge—such as alternative medicine, astrology, quantum
mysticism, spiritualism, and theosophy.[6] Thus, New Age conspiracy theorists,
such as the makers of documentary films like Esoteric Agenda, claim that
globalists who plot on behalf of the New World Order are simply misusing
occultism for Machiavellian ends, such as adopting 21 December 2012 as the
exact date for the establishment of the New World Order to take advantage of
the growing 2012 phenomenon, which has its origins in the fringe Mayanist
theories of New Age writers José Argüelles, Terence McKenna, and Daniel
Pinchbeck.
Skeptics argue that the connection of conspiracy theorists
and occultists follows from their common fallacious premises. First, any widely
accepted belief must necessarily be false. Second, stigmatized knowledge—what
the Establishment spurns—must be true. The result is a large, self-referential
network in which, for example, some UFO religionists promote anti-Jewish
phobias while some antisemites practice Peruvian shamanism.
Fourth Reich
American writer Jim Marrs claimed that former Nazis and
their sympathizers had been continuing Nazi policies worldwide, especially in
the United States.
Conspiracy theorists often use the term "Fourth Reich" simply as a pejorative synonym for the "New World Order" to imply
that its state ideology and government will be similar to Germany's Third
Reich.
Conspiracy theorists, such as American writer Jim Marrs,
claim that some ex-Nazis, who survived the fall of the Greater German Reich,
along with sympathizers in the United States and elsewhere, given haven by
organizations like ODESSA and Die Spinne, have been working behind the scenes
since the end of World War II to enact at least some principles of Nazism
(e.g., militarism, imperialism, widespread spying on citizens, corporatism, the
use of propaganda to manufacture a national consensus) into culture,
government, and business worldwide. Still, primarily in the U.S., They cite the
influence of ex-Nazi scientists brought in under Operation Paperclip to help
advance aerospace manufacturing in the U.S. with technological principles from
Nazi UFOs, and the acquisition and creation of conglomerates by ex-Nazis and
their sympathizers after the war, in both Europe and the U.S.
This neo-Nazi conspiracy is said to be animated by an "Iron Dream" in which the
American Empire, having thwarted the Judeo-Masonic conspiracy and overthrown
its Zionist Occupation Government, gradually establishes a Fourth Reich
formerly known as the "Western
Imperium"—a pan-Aryan world empire modeled after Adolf Hitler's New
Order—which reverses the "decline of
the West" and ushers a golden age of white supremacy.
Skeptics argue that conspiracy theorists grossly overestimate
the influence of ex-Nazis and neo-Nazis on American society and point out that
political repression at home and imperialism abroad have a long history in the
United States that predates the 20th century. Political theorist Sheldon Wolin
has expressed concern that the twin forces of democratic deficit and superpower
status have paved the way in the U.S. for the emergence of an inverted
totalitarianism that contradicts many principles of Nazism.
Alien invasion
Since the late 1970s, extraterrestrials from other habitable
planets or parallel dimensions (such as "Greys")
and intraterrestrials from Hollow Earth (such as "Reptilians") have been included in the New World Order
conspiracy, in more or less dominant roles, as in the theories put forward by
American writers Stan Deyo and Milton William Cooper, and British writer David
Icke.
The common theme in these conspiracy theories is that aliens
have been among us for decades, centuries, or millennia. Still, a government
cover-up enforced by "Men in
Black" has shielded the public from knowledge of a secret alien
invasion. Motivated by speciesism and imperialism, these aliens have been and
are secretly manipulating developments and changes in human society to more
efficiently control and exploit human beings. In some theories, alien
infiltrators have shapeshifted into human form and moved freely throughout human
society, even to the point of taking control of command positions in
governmental, corporate, and religious institutions, and are now in the final
stages of their plan to take over the world. A mythical covert government
agency of the United States code-named Majestic 12 is often imagined being the
shadow government that collaborates with the alien occupation and permits
alien abductions, in exchange for assistance in the development and testing of
military "flying saucers"
at Area 51, for United States armed forces to achieve full-spectrum
dominance.
Skeptics, who adhere to the psychosocial hypothesis for
unidentified flying objects, argue that the convergence of New World Order
conspiracy theory and UFO conspiracy theory is a product of not only the era's
widespread mistrust of governments and the popularity of the extraterrestrial
hypothesis for UFOs but of the far right and ufologists joining forces. Barkun
notes that the only positive side to this development is that, if conspirators
plotting to rule the world are believed to be aliens, traditional human
scapegoats (Freemasons, Illuminati, Jews, etc.) are downgraded or exonerated.
Brave New World
Antiscience and neo-Luddite conspiracy theorists emphasize
technology forecasting in their New World Order conspiracy theories. They
speculate that the global power elite are reactionary modernists pursuing a
transhumanist plan to develop and use human enhancement technologies to become a
"posthuman ruling caste",
while change accelerates toward a technological singularity—a theorized future
point of discontinuity when events will accelerate at such a pace that normal
unenhanced humans will be unable to predict or even understand the rapid
changes occurring in the world around them. Conspiracy theorists fear the
outcome will either be the emergence of a Brave New World-like dystopia—a
"Brave New World Order"—or
the extinction of the human species.
Democratic transhumanists, such as American sociologist
James Hughes, counter that many influential members of the United States
establishment are bioconservatives strongly opposed to human enhancement, as
demonstrated by President Bush's Council on Bioethics's proposed international
treaty prohibiting human cloning and germline engineering. Furthermore, he
argues that conspiracy theorists underestimate how fringe the transhumanist
movement really is.
Postulated
implementations
Just as there are several overlapping or conflicting
theories among conspiracists about the nature of the New World Order, so are
there several beliefs about how its architects and planners will implement it:
Gradualism
Conspiracy theorists generally speculate that the New World
Order is being implemented gradually, citing the formation of the U.S. Federal
Reserve System in 1913; the League of Nations in 1919; the International
Monetary Fund in 1944; the United Nations in 1945; the World Bank in 1945; the
World Health Organization in 1948; the European Union and the Euro in 1993; the
World Trade Organization in 1998; the African Union in 2002, and the Union of
South American Nations in 2008 as major milestones.
An increasingly popular conspiracy theory among American
right-wing populists is that the hypothetical North American Union and the
amero currency, proposed by the Council on Foreign Relations and its
counterparts in Mexico and Canada, will be the next milestone in the
implementation of the New World Order. The theory holds that a group of shadowy
and mostly nameless international elites is planning to replace the federal
government of the United States with a transnational government. Therefore,
conspiracy theorists believe the borders between Mexico, Canada, and the United
States are in the process of being erased, covertly, by a group of globalists
whose ultimate goal is to replace national governments in Washington, D.C.,
Ottawa, and Mexico City with a European-style political union and a bloated
E.U.-style bureaucracy.
Skeptics argue that the North American Union exists only as
a proposal contained in one of a thousand academic and policy papers published
each year that advocate all manner of idealistic but ultimately unrealistic
approaches to social, economic, and political problems. Most of these are
passed around in their circles and eventually filed away and forgotten by
junior staffers in congressional offices. However, some of these papers become
touchstones for the conspiracy-minded and form the basis of all kinds of
unfounded xenophobic fears, especially during times of economic anxiety.
For example, in March 2009, as a result of the late-2000s
financial crisis, the People's Republic of China and the Russian Federation
pressed for urgent consideration of a new international reserve currency, and
the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development proposed greatly
expanding the I.M.F.'s special drawing rights. Conspiracy theorists fear these
proposals are a call for the U.S. to adopt a single global currency for a New
World Order.
Judging that both national governments and global
institutions have proven ineffective in addressing global problems that go
beyond the capacity of individual nation-states to solve, some political
scientists critical of New World Order conspiracism, such as Mark C. Partridge,
argue that regionalism will be the major force in the coming decades, pockets
of power around regional centers: Western Europe around Brussels, the Western
Hemisphere around Washington, D.C., East Asia around Beijing, and Eastern Europe
around Moscow. As such, the E.U., the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation, and
the G-20 will likely become more influential as time progresses. The question
then is not whether global governance is gradually emerging, but rather how
will these regional powers interact with one another.
Coup d'état
American right-wing populist conspiracy theorists,
especially those who joined the militia movement in the United States,
speculate that the New World Order will be implemented through a dramatic coup
d'état by a "secret team",
using black helicopters, in the U.S. and other nation-states to bring about a
totalitarian world government controlled by the United Nations and enforced by
troops of foreign U.N. peacekeepers. Following the Rex 84 and Operation Garden
Plot plans, this military coup would involve the suspension of the
Constitution, the imposition of martial law, and the appointment of military
commanders to head state and local governments and to detain dissidents.
These conspiracy theorists, who are all strong believers in
the right to keep and bear arms, are extremely fearful that the passing of any
gun control legislation will be later followed by the abolition of personal gun
ownership and a campaign of gun confiscation, and that the refugee camps of
emergency management agencies such as FEMA will be used for the internment of
suspected subversives, making little effort to distinguish true threats to the
New World Order from pacifist dissidents.
Before 2000, some survivalists wrongly believed this process
would be set in motion by the predicted Y2K problem causing societal collapse.
Since many left-wing and right-wing conspiracy theorists believe that the 11
September attacks were a false flag operation carried out by the United States
intelligence community, as part of a strategy of tension to justify political
repression at home and preemptive war abroad, they have become convinced that a
more catastrophic terrorist incident will be responsible for triggering
Executive Directive 51 to complete the transition to a police state.
Skeptics argue that unfounded fears about an imminent or
eventual gun ban, military coup, internment, or U.N. invasion and occupation
are rooted in the siege mentality of the American militia movement but also an
apocalyptic millenarianism which provides a basic narrative within the
political right in the U.S., claiming that the idealized society (i.e.,
constitutional republic, Jeffersonian democracy, "Christian nation", "white nation") is thwarted
by subversive conspiracies of liberal secular humanists who want "Big Government" and
globalists who plot on behalf of the New World Order.
Mass surveillance
Conspiracy theorists concerned with surveillance abuse
believe that the New World Order is being implemented by the cult of
intelligence at the core of the surveillance-industrial complex through mass
surveillance and the use of Social Security numbers, the bar-coding of retail
goods with Universal Product Code markings, and, most recently, RFID tagging by
microchip implants.
Claiming that corporations and government are planning to
track every move of consumers and citizens with RFID as the latest step toward
a 1984-like surveillance state, consumer privacy advocates, such as Katherine
Albrecht and Liz McIntyre, have become Christian conspiracy theorists who
believe spychips must be resisted because they argue that modern database and
communications technologies, coupled with point of sale data-capture equipment
and sophisticated ID and authentication systems, now make it possible to
require a biometrically associated number or mark to make purchases. They fear
that the ability to implement such a system closely resembles the Number of the
Beast prophesied in the Book of Revelation.
In January 2002, the Information Awareness Office (IAO) was
established by the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) to bring
together several DARPA projects focused on applying information technology to
counter asymmetric threats to national security. Following public criticism
that the development and deployment of these technologies could potentially
lead to a mass surveillance system, the IAO was defunded by the United States Congress
in 2003. The second source of controversy involved IAO's original logo, which
depicted the "all-seeing"
Eye of Providence atop of a pyramid looking down over the globe; accompanied by
the Latin phrase scientia est potentia (knowledge is power). Although DARPA
eventually removed the logo from its website, it left a lasting impression on
privacy advocates. It also inflamed conspiracy theorists, who misinterpret the "eye and pyramid" as the
Masonic symbol of the Illuminati, an 18th-century secret society they speculate
continues to exist and is plotting on behalf of a New World Order.
American historian Richard Landes, who specialized in the
history of apocalypticism and was co-founder and director of the Center for
Millennial Studies at Boston University, argues that new and emerging
technologies often trigger alarmism among millenarians. Even the introduction
of Gutenberg's printing press in 1436 caused waves of apocalyptic thinking. The
Year 2000 problem, bar codes, and Social Security numbers all triggered
end-time warnings which either proved to be false or were no longer taken
seriously once the public became accustomed to these technological changes.
Civil libertarians argue that the privatization of surveillance and the rise of
the surveillance-industrial complex in the United States does raise legitimate
concerns about the erosion of privacy. However, skeptics of mass surveillance
conspiracism caution that such concerns should be disentangled from secular
paranoia about Big Brother or religious hysteria about the Antichrist.
Occultism
Conspiracy theorists of the Christian right, starting with
British revisionist historian Nesta Helen Webster, believe there is an ancient
occult conspiracy—started by the first mystagogues of Gnosticism and
perpetuated by their alleged esoteric successors, such as the Kabbalists,
Cathars, Knights Templar, Hermeticists, Rosicrucians, Freemasons, and,
ultimately, the Illuminati—which seeks to subvert the Judeo-Christian
foundations of the Western world and implement the New World Order through a
one-world religion that prepares the masses to embrace the imperial cult of the
Antichrist. More broadly, they speculate that globalists who plot on behalf of
a New World Order are directed by occult agencies of some sort: unknown
superiors, spiritual hierarchies, demons, fallen angels or Lucifer. They believe
that these conspirators use the power of occult sciences (numerology), symbols
(Eye of Providence), rituals (Masonic degrees), monuments (National Mall
landmarks), buildings (Manitoba Legislative Building), and facilities (Denver
International Airport) to advance their plot to rule the world.
For example, in June 1979, an unknown benefactor under the
pseudonym "R. C. Christian"
had a huge granite megalith built in the U.S. state of Georgia, which acts like
a compass, calendar, and clock. A message comprising ten guides is inscribed on
the occult structure in many languages to serve as instructions for survivors
of a doomsday event to establish a more enlightened and sustainable
civilization than the destroyed one. The "Georgia
Guidestones" has subsequently become a spiritual and political
Rorschach test onto which any number of ideas can be imposed. Some New Agers
and neo-pagans revere it as a ley-line power nexus while a few conspiracy
theorists are convinced that they are engraved with the New World Order's
anti-Christian "Ten
Commandments." Should the Guidestones survive for centuries as their
creators intended, many more meanings could arise, equally unrelated to the designer's
original intention.
Skeptics argue that the demonization of Western esotericism
by conspiracy theorists is rooted in religious intolerance but also in the same
moral panics that have fueled witch trials in the Early Modern period, and
satanic ritual abuse allegations in the United States.
Population control
Conspiracy theorists believe that the New World Order will
also be implemented through human population control to more easily monitor and
control the movement of individuals. The means range from stopping the growth
of human societies through reproductive health and family planning programs,
which promote abstinence, contraception, and abortion, or intentionally reducing
the bulk of the world population through genocides by mongering unnecessary
wars, through plagues by engineering emergent viruses and tainting vaccines,
and through environmental disasters by controlling the weather (HAARP,
chemtrails), etc. Conspiracy theorists argue that globalists plotting on behalf
of a New World Order are neo-Malthusians who engage in overpopulation and
climate change alarmism to create public support for coercive population
control and ultimately world government. United Nations Agenda 21 is condemned
as "reconcentrating" people
into urban areas and depopulating rural ones, even generating a dystopian novel
by Glenn Beck where single-family homes are a distant memory.
Skeptics argue that fears of population control can be
traced back to the traumatic legacy of the eugenics movement's "war against the weak" in the
United States during the first decades of the 20th century but also the Second
Red Scare in the U.S. during the late 1940s and 1950s, and to a lesser extent
in the 1960s, when activists on the far right of American politics routinely
opposed public health programs, notably water fluoridation, mass vaccination
and mental health services, by asserting they were all part of a far-reaching
plot to impose a socialist or communist regime. Their views were influenced by
opposition to several major social and political changes that had happened
in recent years: the growth of internationalism, particularly the United
Nations and its programs; the introduction of social welfare provisions,
particularly the various programs established by the New Deal; and government
efforts to reduce inequalities in the social structure of the U.S. Opposition
towards mass vaccinations in particular got significant attention in the late
2010s, so much so the World Health Organization listed vaccine hesitancy as one
of the top ten global health threats of 2019. By this time, people that refused
or refused to allow their children to be vaccinated were known colloquially as "anti-vaxxers", though citing
the New World Order conspiracy theory or resistance to a perceived population
control plan as a reason to refuse vaccination were few and far between.
Mind control
Social critics accuse governments, corporations, and the
mass media of being involved in the manufacturing of a national consensus and,
paradoxically, a culture of fear due to the potential for increased social control
that a mistrustful and mutually fearing population might offer to those in
power. The worst fear of some conspiracy theorists, however, is that the New
World Order will be implemented through the use of mind control—a broad range
of tactics able to subvert an individual's control of their own thinking,
behavior, emotions, or decisions. These tactics are said to include everything
from Manchurian candidate-style brainwashing of sleeper agents (Project
MKULTRA, "Project Monarch") to
engineering psychological operations (water fluoridation, subliminal
advertising, "Silent Sound Spread
Spectrum", MEDUSA) and parapsychological operations (Stargate Project)
to influence the masses. The concept of wearing a tin foil hat for protection
from such threats has become a popular stereotype and term of derision; the
phrase serves as a byword for paranoia and is associated with conspiracy
theorists.
Skeptics argue that the paranoia behind a conspiracy
theorist's obsession with mind control, population control, occultism,
surveillance abuse, Big Business, Big Government, and globalization arises from
a combination of two factors when he or she: 1) holds strong individualist
values and 2) lacks power. The first attribute refers to people who care deeply
about an individual's right to make their own choices and direct their own
lives without interference or obligations to a larger system (like the
government), but combine this with a sense of powerlessness in one's own life.
One gets what some psychologists call "agency
panic," intense anxiety about an apparent loss of autonomy to outside
forces or regulators. When fervent individualists feel that they cannot
exercise their independence, they experience a crisis and assume that larger
forces are to blame for usurping this freedom.
Alleged conspirators
According to Domhoff, many people seem to believe that the
United States is ruled behind the scenes by a conspiratorial elite with
secret desires, i.e., by a small, secretive group that wants to change the government
system or put the country under the control of a world government. In the past,
the conspirators were usually said to be crypto-communists who were intent on
bringing the United States under a common world government with the Soviet
Union, but the dissolution of the USSR in 1991 undercut that theory. Domhoff
notes that most conspiracy theorists changed their focus to the United Nations
as the likely controlling force in a New World Order, an idea which is
undermined by the powerlessness of the U.N. and the unwillingness of even
moderates within the American Establishment to give it anything but a limited
role.
Although skeptical of New World Order conspiracism,
political scientist David Rothkopf argues, in the 2008 book Superclass: The
Global Power Elite and the World They Are Making, that the world population of
6 billion people is governed by an elite of 6,000 individuals. Until the late 20th
century, governments of the great powers provided most of the superclass,
accompanied by a few heads of international movements (i.e., the Pope of the
Catholic Church) and entrepreneurs (Rothschilds, Rockefellers). According to
Rothkopf, in the early 21st century, economic clout—fueled by the explosive
expansion of international trade, travel, and communication—rules; the
nation-state's power has diminished shrinking politicians to minority power
broker status; leaders in international business, finance, and the defense
industry not only dominate the superclass, but they also move freely into high
positions in their nations' governments and back to private life largely beyond
the notice of elected legislatures (including the U.S. Congress), which remain
abysmally ignorant of affairs beyond their borders. He asserts that the
superclass' disproportionate influence over national policy is constructive but
always self-interested and that across the world, few object to corruption and
oppressive governments provided they can do business in these countries.
Viewing the history of the world as the history of warfare
between secret societies, conspiracy theorists go further than Rothkopf, and
other scholars who have studied the global power elite, by claiming that
established upper-class families with "old
money" who founded and finance the Bilderberg Group, Bohemian Club,
Club of Rome, Council on Foreign Relations, Rhodes Trust, Skull and Bones,
Trilateral Commission, and similar think tanks and private clubs, are
illuminated conspirators plotting to impose a totalitarian New World Order—the
implementation of an authoritarian world government controlled by the United
Nations and a global central bank, which maintains political power through the
financialization of the economy, regulation and restriction of speech through
the concentration of media ownership, mass surveillance, widespread use of
state terrorism, and an all-encompassing propaganda that creates a cult of
personality around a puppet world leader and ideologizes world government as
the culmination of history's progress.
Criticism
Skeptics of New World Order conspiracy theories accuse its
proponents of indulging in the furtive fallacy, a belief that significant facts
of history are necessarily sinister; conspiracism, a worldview that centrally
places conspiracy theories in the unfolding of history, rather than social and
economic forces; and fusion paranoia, a promiscuous absorption of fears from
any source whatsoever.
Marxists, who are skeptical of right-wing populist
conspiracy theories, also accuse the global power elite of not having the best
interests of all at heart, and many intergovernmental organizations of
suffering from a democratic deficit, but they argue that the superclass are
plutocrats only interested in brazenly imposing a neoliberal or neoconservative
new world order—the implementation of global capitalism through economic and
military coercion to protect the interests of transnational corporations—which
systematically undermines the possibility of international socialism. Arguing
that the world is in the middle of a transition from the American Empire to the
rule of a global ruling class that has emerged from within the American Empire,
they point out that right-wing populist conspiracy theorists, blinded by their
anti-communism, fail to see that what they demonize as the "New World Order" is, ironically, the highest stage of
the very capitalist economic system they defend.
Domhoff, a research professor in psychology and sociology
who studies theories of power, wrote in 2005 an essay entitled There Are No
Conspiracies. He says that for this theory to be true, it required several "wealthy and highly educated
people" to do things that don't "fit
with what we know about power structures". Claims that this will
happen go back decades and have always been proved wrong.
Partridge, a contributing editor to the global affairs
magazine Diplomatic Courier, wrote a 2008 article entitled One World
Government: Conspiracy Theory or Inevitable Future? He says that if anything,
nationalism, which is the opposite of a global government, is rising. He also
says that attempts at creating global governments or global agreements "have been categorical failures" and
where "supranational governance
exists they are noted for their bureaucracy and inefficiency."
Although some cultural critics see super-conspiracy theories
about a New World Order as "postmodern
metanarratives" that may be politically empowering, a way of giving
ordinary people a narrative structure with which to question what they see
around them, skeptics argue that conspiracism leads people into cynicism,
convoluted thinking, and a tendency to feel it is hopeless even as they denounce
the alleged conspirators.
Alexander Zaitchik from the Southern Poverty Law Center
wrote a report titled "'Patriot'
Paranoia: A Look at the Top Ten Conspiracy Theories", in which he
personally condemns such conspiracies as an effort of the radical right to
undermine society.
Concerned that the improvisational millennialism of most
conspiracy theories about a New World Order might motivate lone wolves to
engage in leaderless resistance leading to domestic terrorist incidents like
the Oklahoma City bombing, Barkun writes that "the danger lies less in such beliefs themselves ... than in the
behavior they might stimulate or justify" and warns "should they believe that the
prophesied evil day had in fact arrived, their behavior would become far more
difficult to predict."
Warning of the threat to American democracy posed by
right-wing populist movements led by demagogues who mobilize support for mob
rule or even a fascist revolution by exploiting the fear of conspiracies,
Berlet writes that "Right-wing
populist movements can cause serious damage to society because they often
popularize xenophobia, authoritarianism, scapegoating, and conspiracism. This
can lure mainstream politicians to adopt these themes to attract voters,
legitimize acts of discrimination (or even violence), and open the door for
revolutionary right-wing populist movements, such as fascism, to recruit from
the reformist populist movements."
Hughes, a professor of religion, warns that no religious
idea has greater potential for shaping global politics in profoundly negative
ways than "the new world
order". In a February 2011 article entitled Revelation, Revolutions, and the Tyrannical New World Order, he writes that "the crucial piece of this puzzle is the identity of the
Antichrist, the tyrannical figure who both leads and inspires the new world
order". This has in turn been the Soviet Union and the Arab world. He says
that inspires believers to "welcome war with the Islamic world" and
opens the door to nuclear holocaust."
Criticisms of New World Order conspiracy theorists also come
from within their own community. Despite believing themselves to be "freedom fighters", many
right-wing populist conspiracy theorists hold views that are incompatible with
their professed libertarianisms, such as Christian dominionism, authoritarian
ultranationalism, white supremacy, and eliminationism. This paradox has led
Icke, who argues that Christian Patriots are the only Americans who understand
the truth about the New World Order (which he believes is controlled by a race
of reptilians known as the "Babylonian
Brotherhood"), to reportedly tell a Christian Patriot group, "I don't know which I dislike more, the
world controlled by the Brotherhood or the one you want to replace it
with."