Between 2010 and 2017, a total of eight men disappeared from the neighborhood of Church and Wellesley, the LGBTQ village of Toronto, Ontario, Canada. The investigation into the disappearances, taken up by two successive police task forces, eventually led to Bruce McArthur, a 66-year-old self-employed Toronto landscaper, whom they then arrested on January 18, 2018. On January 29, 2019, McArthur pleaded guilty to eight counts of first-degree murder in Ontario Superior Court and was subsequently sentenced to life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for twenty-five years. McArthur is the most prolific known serial killer to have been active in Toronto, and the oldest known serial killer in Canada.
The criminal investigation of McArthur became the largest
ever conducted by the Toronto Police Service (TPS) and also called on the
resources of the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP), Royal Canadian Mounted Police
(RCMP) and other police and forensic services. Criticisms of the TPS's handling
of the initial missing persons investigations led to several internal reviews,
an external review called by the civilian Toronto Police Services Board (TPSB)
and the formation of a dedicated missing persons unit.
Early life
Thomas Donald Bruce McArthur, or Bruce McArthur, was born on
October 8, 1951, in Lindsay, Ontario, and was raised on a farm in Argyle, in
the Kawartha Lakes region. In addition to raising McArthur and his sister, his
parents fostered troubled children from nearby Toronto, often with six to ten
in their care at any given time, and reportedly had a good reputation in the
area.
McArthur's mother was Irish Catholic and his father a
Scottish Presbyterian; both were devout, causing religious arguments in which
McArthur supported his mother. This led to derision from his father, who
McArthur suggested in retrospect may have sensed his homosexuality. McArthur
had trouble accepting his sexual orientation, which would have been seen as
abnormal in rural Ontario at that time.
In primary school, a classmate recalled that McArthur did
not fit in with other students. For his secondary education, McArthur was bused
to nearby Fenelon Falls Secondary School, where he met and began dating Janice
Campbell, both graduating in 1970. McArthur later graduated from a program in
general business and married Campbell when he was aged 23.
Married life
Around 1973, McArthur began working at an Eaton's department
store in downtown Toronto as a buyer's assistant. He left this employment in
1978 and began working as a travelling salesman for McGregor Socks, soliciting
department stores to carry his merchandise. McArthur later worked as a
merchandising representative for Stanfield's, a garment company.
In the mid-1970s, McArthur's father was diagnosed with a
brain tumor and was sent to a nursing home. McArthur became disappointed when
his mother took interest in another man, and grew much closer to his father at
this time. His mother died of cancer in 1978 and his father died in 1981.
In 1979, McArthur and his wife moved into a house on Ormond
Drive in Oshawa; by 1981 they had a daughter, Melanie, and a son, Todd. In
1986, the family bought a home on Cartref Avenue in Oshawa. McArthur became very active in his church,
keeping himself busy to avoid examining his homosexual feelings.
McArthur began having affairs with men in the early 1990s.
He came out to his wife more than a year later, but they continued living
together. Sometime after 1993, McArthur's employment in the clothing trade came
to an end. The couple faced financial difficulty, in part due to legal issues
connected to their then-teenaged son, Todd, who had been prosecuted for making
obscene phone calls to women. The couple mortgaged their home in 1997 and
declared bankruptcy in 1999.
McArthur separated from his wife in 1997 and moved to
Toronto, as there was no gay community in Oshawa at that time. He frequented
the bars of Church and Wellesley, Toronto's gay village, and moved into an
apartment on Don Mills Road while pursuing a four-year relationship with
another man. When they broke up and his divorce was being finalized, McArthur
saw a psychiatrist and was prescribed Prozac for several months. At about this
time he began his career as a landscaper.
Halloween assault
Just after noon on October 31, 2001, McArthur followed actor
and model Mark Henderson into his apartment after being invited inside to see
his Halloween costume. McArthur struck Henderson several times from behind with
an iron pipe that he often carried. Henderson fought back before losing
consciousness. After waking he called 9-1-1 then was taken to St. Michael's
Hospital, where he needed several stitches on the back of his head and his
fingers, as well as six weeks of physiotherapy.
McArthur turned himself in after the attack, claiming to not
to remember the attack. He pleaded guilty to charges of assault with a weapon
and assault causing bodily harm, and received a conditional sentence of 729
days (two years less a day) on April 11, 2003. A further charge of carrying a
concealed weapon was withdrawn at the time. The Crown had earlier believed jail
time was warranted but agreed to conditional sentence after psychiatric and
pre-sentencing reports suggested McArthur was a low risk to reoffend.
Henderson, was traumatized by the incident, and did not provide a victim impact
statement for the sentencing. There were also concerns that McArthur's
behaviour may have been due to the combination of his anti-seizure medication
with amyl nitrite, a muscle relaxant which is sometimes taken recreationally
before sex.
McArthur avoided incarceration, spending the first year of
his sentence under house arrest, followed by a six-month curfew and three years
of probation. During the sentence, he was barred from Church and Wellesley
except for work and medical appointments, had to stay at least 10 metres (33
ft) from Henderson's home or workplace, and could not spend time with "male prostitutes". McArthur
was forbidden to possess firearms for ten years; was not to purchase, possess
or consume drugs without a medical prescription; and was specifically barred
from possessing amyl nitrite. He also had to submit his DNA to a database and
was compelled to undertake psychological and psychiatric counselling, including
anger management. A defense lawyer found the list of conditions uncommon and
suggested that the judge was concerned that McArthur still posed a danger. A
retired detective noted that parole conditions at the time were unenforceable,
were not publicized, and that parole violators were caught only if they
attracted police attention.
In 2014, McArthur was granted a record suspension on the
2003 conviction, which was subsequently expunged from his record and would not
have appeared in criminal background checks. Most records and exhibits
pertaining to the case were destroyed in 2010, in compliance with Toronto
Police Service (TPS) retention policy. The only surviving documents were the
transcripts of the guilty plea and sentencing hearing, the psychiatric report
and presentencing report ordered during the trial, and pictures of Henderson's
injuries and McArthur's weapon.
Additional background
In 2002, while the assault case was still pending, McArthur
registered with Recon, a gay fetish dating website for men into BDSM.
McArthur's profile noted his interest in submissive men. He was also active on
numerous gay dating websites including Silverdaddies, Manjam, Grindr, Bear411,
BearForest, Scruff, DaddyHunt, Squirt and Growlr. McArthur joined Facebook in
2011 and catalogued his participation in local nightlife, with younger men of
South Asian or Middle Eastern descent in several photos. By this time McArthur
had reestablished himself in Toronto's gay community and was a regular at gay
bars. By the late 2000s he was living in a 19th-floor apartment in Thorncliffe
Park, about 5 kilometres (3 mi) northeast of Church and Wellesley.
McArthur's banishment from Church and Wellesley over the
2001 assault remained well known, and he had developed a reputation for BDSM
and rough sex. In 2011, he told an acquaintance named Robert James about an
incident in which he had reacted violently after being asked to leave a
coffeehouse. James decided to heed advice to stay away from McArthur,
explaining that he had heard disturbing stories about him. According to James,
McArthur turned red and screamed about "f---ing
f---ots [sic] telling stories about me!" and, "You're just like the rest of them, you think I'm crazy."
A. J. Khan, a Toronto restaurant owner, recalled questioning McArthur in 2013
when he came in alone instead of with his boyfriend. McArthur said his
boyfriend was on vacation, and when Khan noted he had seen the man the previous
day, he angrily left and never returned.
McArthur's landscaping business operated under the name
Artistic Designs. A colleague who installed water features on three of his
projects recalled that McArthur was always accompanied by an older white man,
who appeared to be romantically involved with him, and a day laborer, usually
of Southeast Asian or Middle Eastern descent. Most of McArthur's clients were
wealthy elderly women who found him charming, and he had built a client base
through personal recommendations. During the off-season, he portrayed Santa
Claus at Agincourt Mall and made floral gifts for charities.
McArthur's separation from his wife was initially heated,
though they later reconciled. His son was reported to have difficulty accepting
his father's sexuality. In 2014, after Todd was sentenced to fourteen months in
jail for making multiple obscene phone calls, he was released on bail and
ordered to live with his father and assist with his landscaping business. A
former friend of Todd's visited one night and discovered the wall of McArthur's
bathroom was decorated with photos of naked "East
Indian" men. Todd told him that they were men whom his father knew.
McArthur did not hide the fact, laughing over it at breakfast.
Missing person’s
investigations
Project Houston
In November 2012, the TPS launched a task force, dubbed "Project Houston", into the
September 6, 2010, disappearance of Skandaraj "Skanda" Navaratnam, believing that he had been murdered.
The investigation was launched after a man posted on the cannibal web forum
Zambian Meat that he had killed and eaten a man in Toronto. Police briefly
investigated a possible link between Navaratnam and convicted murderer Luka
Magnotta, but this lead was eventually abandoned for lack of evidence.
By June 2013, Project Houston had identified two other
missing people’s cases linked by geography and lifestyle: Abdulbasir "Basir" Faizi and Majeed "Hamid" Kayhan. Like
Navaratnam, both men were middle-aged South Asian immigrants who disappeared
from Church and Wellesley between 2010 and 2012. An anonymous tip linking
McArthur to Navaratnam and Kayhan led police to interview him on November 11,
2013. McArthur stated that he regularly interacted with Navaratnam at a gay
bar, but denied being in a relationship with him. He also admitted to employing
Kayhan, with whom he had broken off a sexual relationship. Project Houston
concluded with no evidence to link the disappearances, that a crime had been
committed or to identify a suspect. According to a 2016 case summary, there was
still nothing to explain what had happened to the three men.
Missing Rainbow
Community
On June 26, 2017, one day after attending Pride Toronto,
Andrew Kinsman disappeared near his residence on Winchester Street in
Cabbagetown. On the evening of June 28, several friends gained access to
Kinsman's apartment. They found no sign of disturbance, though his 17-year-old
cat was out of food and water. Noting that Kinsman's life was stable and that
he would never leave without notifying anyone or taking his cat and
prescription medicine, the friends reported the disappearance to the TPS the
following day. Kinsman was active on social media, but investigators found his
cell phone was turned off the day he disappeared.
Composite of 11
missing persons notices
At the end of July 2017, the TPS created a new task force,
Project Prism, to investigate the disappearances of Kinsman and another man,
Selim Esen, and to look for any links with the unsolved disappearances
investigated under Project Houston. Greg Downer, a friend and colleague of
Kinsman's, organized a community safety meeting on August 1 in which police
gave an overview of the task force. Realizing the difficulty police faced with
judicial authorizations for data from servers located outside Canada, which
caused crucial delays in the missing persons investigations, Downer appealed to
dating apps to provide an option for users to consent to have their data
released to police if they went missing. Safety hotlines were also set up for
those reluctant to speak to police.
Fears of a serial killer stalking Church and Wellesley grew
on November 29 when the body of Tess Richey was found by her mother in an
alleyway four days after she was reported missing. The following day, police
announced that the body of Alloura Wells, a homeless transgender woman, had
been identified, her body having been discovered in a Rosedale ravine in
August. Because of fears in the community, TPS Chief Mark Saunders held an
unprecedented December 8 news conference on the three separate investigations.
Although the cases occurred in close proximity, the TPS did not believe they
were related and Saunders said they had no evidence of a serial killer.
Project Prism
Project Prism was overseen by Detective Sergeant Michael
Richmond and led by Detective Sergeant Hank Idsinga, who had served on the
homicide squad for over thirteen years and had been assigned to Project Houston
for six months. The task force also included an officer from the sex crimes
unit and six officers from Police 51 Division, three of whom had been members
of Project Houston. The investigation was difficult because of the lifestyle of
the subjects, who used dating apps and frequently met strangers.
Kinsman's disappearance was central to the creation of
Project Prism because of a lead obtained at the end of July. According to an
agreed statement of facts read in court, police found "Bruce" on Kinsman's calendar for June 26 – the
same day Kinsman was last seen. Surveillance video outside Kinsman's residence
showed a person matching his appearance approach a red vehicle. The video did
not show a licence plate or a clear picture of the driver, but chrome siding
identified it as a 2004 Dodge Caravan. There were more than 6,000 similar
models in Toronto, but only five were registered to someone named Bruce; of
those the only 2004 model belonged to McArthur. By late August or September
2017, police matched the van from surveillance video of McArthur's apartment,
but it was no longer at his residence.
Redacted warrants and police documents, partially released
by a judge in mid-2018, revealed that in August and September investigators had
obtained production orders compelling the release of McArthur's data from
Google, Rogers Wireless, Bell Canada, Telus, Royal Bank of Canada and Manulife
Bank of Canada. Around September, tracking warrants had been obtained for McArthur's
vehicles and phones. In October, further orders were granted for information
from Yahoo!, Air Canada, additional banks and Pink Triangle Press, an LGBT
publisher.
On October 3, plainclothes officers visited at Dom's Auto
Parts in Courtice, Ontario, 70 kilometers (43 mi) northeast of Toronto, where
owner Dominic Vetere confirmed he had purchased McArthur's Caravan on September
16. Police found it intact and had it towed away, also copying surveillance
video of McArthur visiting the shop. Vetere said that officers later told him
that they had found trace amounts of blood in the vehicle. This blood was
identified as Kinsman's.
Court documents show that, in November, cadaver dogs were
brought to a Mallory Crescent residence in the Leaside neighbourhood of
Toronto. McArthur had an arrangement to tend to the owners' yard in exchange
for storage space in their garage. The dogs did not indicate any human remains.
A camera was installed to monitor the garage. Police also obtained a log of
McArthur's key fob for his apartment. With this and a tracking warrant for his
cellphone, they built a timeline of the day Kinsman went missing. DNA evidence
from the Caravan which matched Kinsman and Esen, which allowed investigators to
obtain a general warrant for McArthur's apartment on December 4. Police
covertly entered his residence and cloned his computer's hard drive.
In a December 8 news conference, investigators stated they
had completed 62 witness interviews, 28 judicial authorizations and assigned
308 actions, of which 225 had been completed. Police had also conducted
searches, utilizing resources from the mounted and canine units; on one
occasion a drone was used. They said that they had no evidence to link the
disappearances.
The investigation picked up in January 2018, when Idsinga
noted they had many 15-hour days and a 72-hour stretch of intensive investigation
in mid-January. On January 17, two pieces of evidence came to light directly
connecting McArthur to Esen and Kinsman. A partial download from his computer,
which was going through forensic analysis of deleted files, yielded post-mortem
photos of the victims. Round-the-clock surveillance was put on McArthur, with
instructions that he should be immediately arrested if observed "alone with anyone".
Arrest
Police surveilling McArthur decided to apprehend him shortly
after they saw a young man enter his Thorncliffe Park apartment on January 18,
believing his life was at risk. A source told CTV News that the officers found
the young man restrained on a bed when they entered the apartment. Referred to
in court as "John", the man
had met McArthur through dating app Growlr and had met him for sex several
times. Prior to the police intervention, "John"
had agreed to be handcuffed to McArthur's steel bedframe; McArthur put a black
bag over his head and tried to tape his mouth shut before the rescue.
Following McArthur's arrest, police seized electronic
devices from his apartment, including five cellphones, five computers, three
digital cameras and about a dozen USB flash drives. Evidence found on these
devices prompted investigators to charge him with two counts of first-degree
murder in the presumed deaths of Kinsman and Esen. Their bodies had not been
found, but police said that they had a "pretty
good idea" of how they died. Idsinga was satisfied that there was
enough evidence for murder convictions even without the bodies.
Homicide
investigation
At the time of McArthur's arrest, Idsinga said that police
believed he was responsible for the deaths of other men and were most concerned
with identifying these victims. Doing so included coordinating with other
police services, tracing McArthur's whereabouts and his online activity.
By the end of January, Idsinga described the ongoing case as
unprecedented, with hundreds of officers involved and thirty properties being
searched. The Ontario Provincial Police (OPP), the Ontario Forensic Pathology
Service (OFPS) and the Centre of Forensic Sciences (CFS) aided the searches of
McArthur's apartment and the Leaside property. Additional charges were laid and
at the end of February, the investigation was expanded to outstanding murder
cases, hundreds of missing-persons cases and sudden death occurrences,
coordinating with other Canadian and international forces.
Apartment and Leaside
home
On January 18, police executed search warrants at five
properties associated with McArthur: four in Toronto and a 9-acre (3.6 ha)
property about 200 kilometres (120 mi) northeast in Madoc,
Ontario. The Madoc property and a home on Conlins Road were
residences of Roger Horan, a landscaper and long-time friend of McArthur. Another
property searched was the condominium of McArthur's former boyfriend on
Concorde Place. These three properties were released back to their owners by
January 23. Of greater concern to investigators were McArthur's high-rise
apartment in Thorncliffe Park and the Mallory Crescent residence in Leaside.
The owners of the Leaside residence were barred from their
home to allow a forensic search. The search was extended to an adjacent ravine,
aided by cadaver dogs and members of the heavy urban search and rescue team.
Cadaver dogs took a "strong
interest" in large planter boxes on January 19. The planters had
frozen to the ground, requiring heaters to thaw them. On January 29, police
announced that they had found the dismembered skeletal remains of at least three
people in two of the twelve planters. Although the remains had not been
identified, police had gathered enough evidence to charge McArthur with three
additional counts of first-degree murder in the presumed deaths of Majeed
Kayhan, a Project Houston subject; Soroush Mahmudi, who disappeared in 2015;
and Dean Lisowick, a homeless man who was never reported missing.
On February 8, police announced that they had found the
remains of three more people from the Leaside residence, and that one of the
six sets of remains belonged to Kinsman, identified through fingerprints.
Additional planters were seized from across the city, including one from the
Danforth neighborhood and two properties in North Rosedale. A forensic
pathologist was expected to take at least ten days to excavate for remains at
the Leaside residence by hand. Forensic anthropologist Kathy Gruspier, who
arrived to oversee the excavation, did not find any sign of soil disturbance by
previous digging. Excavation of two sewage lines at the home was conducted on
February 13, and a section of one line was removed for testing.
The investigation had a continuous presence at the Leaside
residence, often described as "ground
zero", and police established a command post on the property. On
February 10–11 the search was completed and it was released to its owners after
more than three weeks. The owners requested that police keep crime scene tape
up around the yard to deter journalists by whom they were feeling increasingly
harassed.
Police believe that some of the murders took place at
McArthur's apartment, where they conducted a four-month forensic search.
Forensic investigators spent hundreds of hours searching
every inch of McArthur's apartment, where Idsinga suspected some of the murders
occurred. It took them several weeks before searching McArthur's bedroom, where
they expected to find the bulk of their evidence. The search concluded on May
11, having occupied ten forensic officers for nearly four months. They took
more than 18,000 photographs and collected over 1,800 items. Idsinga noted the
thoroughness required as the first murder was believed to have occurred eight
years previously. The searches of the Leaside residence and McArthur's
apartment made up the largest forensic investigation conducted by the TPS.
On February 23, McArthur was charged with a sixth count of
first-degree murder in the death of Skandaraj Navaratnam, a subject of Project
Houston. His remains and those of Mahmudi were identified through dental
records, and had been recovered from planters at the Leaside residence.
On March 5, the TPS held a press conference and released a
photo of an unidentified deceased man alleged to be another of McArthur's
victims. Police later received over 500 tips regarding the photo and were
checking on 22 potential identities. They also announced that a seventh set of
remains had been recovered from the Leaside planters. Michael Pollanen,
Ontario's chief forensic pathologist, said his organization had never before
been involved in an investigation with such scope, drawing on the skills of
each member for many unique challenges, such as scientific issues related to
decomposition and post-mortem dismemberment.
On April 11, McArthur was charged with a seventh count of
first-degree murder in the death of Abdulbasir Faizi. He was, at this point,
charged with the deaths of all five men from the Project Houston and Project
Prism investigations. The charge came as Faizi's remains were identified from
the Leaside planters, along with those of Esen and Lisowick. Investigators had
finished searching the Leaside planters, from which the remains of all but
Kayhan had been identified; they had one set of unidentified remains. They had
also searched eight additional planters from elsewhere in the city, which had contained
no human remains.
On April 16, McArthur was charged with an eighth count of
first-degree murder in the death of Kirushna Kumar Kanagaratnam, whose remains
were the seventh set identified from the Leaside planters. Police said his name
had not come from the many tips generated by the release of his post-mortem
photograph but that he had been identified with help from an undisclosed
international agency. Kanagaratnam was a Tamil asylum-seeker who was under a
deportation order and had not been reported missing. Police said they would
look into why his name was not on a list of missing persons. He had last had
contact with his family in August 2015, and police believed that he had been
killed between September 3 and December 14, 2015.
No comments:
Post a Comment