Aftermath of
Wilhelmsbad
What the Convent of Wilhelmsbad actually achieved was the
demise of the Strict Observance. It renounced its own origin myth, along with
the higher degrees which bound its highest and most influential members. It
abolished the strict control which had kept the order united, and alienated
many Germans who mistrusted Martinism. Bode, who was repelled by Martinism,
immediately entered negotiations with Knigge, and finally joined the Illuminati
in January 1783. Charles of Hesse joined the following month.
Knigge's first efforts at an alliance with the intact German
Grand Lodges failed, but Weishaupt persisted. He proposed a new federation
where all of the German lodges would practice an agreed, unified system in the
essential three degrees of Freemasonry, and be left to their own devices as to
which, if any, system of higher degrees they wished to pursue. This would be a
federation of Grand Lodges, and members would be free to visit any of the
"blue" lodges, in any jurisdiction. All lodge masters would be
elected, and no fees would be paid to any central authority whatsoever. Groups
of lodges would be subject to a "Scottish Directorate", composed of
members delegated by lodges, to audit finances, settle disputes, and authorize
new lodges. These in turn would elect Provincial Directorates, who would elect
inspectors, who would elect the national director. This system would correct
the current imbalance in German Freemasonry, where masonic ideals of equality
were preserved only in the lower three "symbolic" degrees. The
various systems of higher degrees were dominated by the elite who could afford
researches in alchemy and mysticism. To Weishaupt and Knigge, the proposed
federation was also a vehicle to propagate Illuminism throughout German
Freemasonry. Their intention was to use their new federation, with its emphasis
on the fundamental degrees, to remove all allegiance to Strict Observance,
allowing the "eclectic" system of the Illuminati to take its place.
The circular announcing the new federation outlined the
faults of German freemasonry, that unsuitable men with money were often
admitted on the basis of their wealth, that the corruption of civil society had
infected the lodges. Having advocated the deregulation of the higher grades of
the German lodges, the Illuminati now announced their own, from their
"unknown Superiors". Lodge Theodore, newly independent from Royal
York, set them up as a provincial Grand Lodge. Knigge, in a letter to all the
Royal York lodges, now accused that Grand Lodge of decadence. Their Freemasonry
had allegedly been corrupted by the Jesuits. Strict Observance was now attacked
as a creation of the Stuarts, devoid of all moral virtue. The Zinnendorf rite
of the Grand Landlodge of the Freemasons of Germany was suspect because its
author was in league with the Swedes. This direct attack had the opposite
effect to that intended by Weishaupt; it offended many of its readers. The
Grand Lodge of the Grand Orient of Warsaw, which controlled Freemasonry in
Poland and Lithuania, was happy to participate in the federation only as far as
the first three degrees. Their insistence on independence had kept them from
the Strict Observance, and would now keep them from the Illuminati, whose plan
to annex Freemasonry rested on their own higher degrees. By the end of January
1783 the Illuminati's masonic contingent had seven lodges.
It was not only the clumsy appeal of the Illuminati that
left the federation short of members. Lodge Theodore was recently formed and
did not command respect like the older lodges. Most of all, the Freemasons most
likely to be attracted to the federation saw the Illuminati as an ally against
the mystics and Martinists, but valued their own freedom too highly to be
caught in another restrictive organization. Even Ditfurth, the supposed
representative of the Illuminati at Wilhelmsbad, had pursued his own agenda at
the convent.
The non-mystical Frankfurt lodges created an "Eclectic
Alliance", which was almost indistinguishable in constitution and aims
from the Illuminati's federation. Far from seeing this as a threat, after some
discussion the Illuminati lodges joined the new alliance. Three Illuminati now
sat on the committee charged with writing the new masonic statutes. Aside from
strengthening relations between their three lodges, the Illuminati seem to have
gained no advantage from this manoeuvre. Ditfurth, having found a masonic
organization that worked towards his own ambitions for Freemasonry, took little
interest in the Illuminati after his adherence to the Eclectic Alliance. In
reality, the creation of the Eclectic Alliance had undermined all of the subtle
plans of the Illuminati to spread their own doctrine through Freemasonry.[
Zenith
Although their hopes of mass recruitment through Freemasonry
had been frustrated, the Illuminati continued to recruit well at an individual
level. In Bavaria, the succession of Charles Theodore initially led to a liberalization
of attitudes and laws, but the clergy and courtiers, guarding their own power
and privilege, persuaded the weak-willed monarch to reverse his reforms, and
Bavaria's repression of liberal thought returned. This reversal led to a
general resentment of the monarch and the church among the educated classes,
which provided a perfect recruiting ground for the Illuminati. A number of
Freemasons from Prudence lodge, disaffected by the Martinist rites of the
Chevaliers Bienfaisants, joined lodge Theodore, who set themselves up in a
gardened mansion which contained their library of liberal literature.
Illuminati circles in the rest of Germany expanded. While
some had only modest gains, the circle in Mainz almost doubled from 31 to 61
members. Reaction to state Catholicism led to gains in Austria, and footholds
were obtained in Warsaw, Pressburg (Bratislava), Tyrol, Milan and Switzerland.
The total number of verifiable members at the end of 1784 is
around 650. Weishaupt and Hertel later claimed a figure of 2,500. The higher
figure is largely explained by the inclusion of members of masonic lodges that
the Illuminati claimed to control, but it is likely that the names of all the
Illuminati are not known, and the true figure lies somewhere between 650 and
2,500. The importance of the order lay in its successful recruitment of the
professional classes, churchmen, academics, doctors and lawyers, and its more
recent acquisition of powerful benefactors. Karl August, Grand Duke of
Saxe-Weimar-Eisenach, Ernest II, Duke of Saxe-Gotha-Altenburg with his brother
and later successor August, Karl Theodor Anton Maria von Dalberg governor of
Erfurt, Duke Ferdinand of Brunswick-Wolfenbüttel (already mentioned), his chief
assistant in masonic matters, Johann Friedrich von Schwarz, and Count
Metternich of Koblenz were all enrolled. In Vienna, Count Brigido, governor of
Galicia, Count Leopold Kolowrat, chancellor of Bohemia with his vice-Chancellor
Baron Kressel, Count Pálffy von Erdöd, chancellor of Hungary, Count Banffy,
governor and provincial Grand Master of Transylvania, Count Stadion, ambassador
to London, and Baron von Swieten, minister of public education, also joined.
There were notable failures. Johann Kaspar Lavater, the
Swiss poet and theologian, rebuffed Knigge. He did not believe the order's
humanitarian and rationalist aims were achievable by secret means. He further
believed that a society's drive for members would ultimately submerge its
founding ideals. Christoph Friedrich Nicolai, the Berlin writer and bookseller,
became disillusioned after joining. He found its aims chimeric, and thought
that the use of Jesuit methods to achieve their aims was dangerous. He remained
in the order, but took no part in recruitment.
Conflict with
Rosicrucians
At all costs, Weishaupt wished to keep the existence of the
order secret from the Rosicrucians, who already had a considerable foothold in
German Freemasonry. While clearly Protestant, the Rosicrucians were anything
but anticlerical, were pro-monarchic, and held views clearly conflicting with
the Illuminati vision of a rationalist state run by philosophers and
scientists. The Rosicrucians were not above promoting their own brand of
mysticism with fraudulent séances. A conflict became inevitable as the
existence of the Illuminati became more evident, and as prominent Rosicrucians,
and mystics with Rosicrucian sympathies, were actively recruited by Knigge and
other over-enthusiastic helpers. Kolowrat was already a high ranking
Rosicrucian, and the mystic Prince Charles of Hesse-Kassel had a very low
opinion of the rationalist higher grades of the Illuminati.
The Prussian Rosicrucians, under Johann Christoph von
Wöllner, began a sustained attack on the Illuminati. Wöllner had a specially
engineered room in which he convinced potential patrons of the effectiveness of
Rosicrucian "magic", and his order had acquired effective control of
the "Three Globes" and its attached lodges. Through this mouthpiece,
the Illuminati were accused of atheism and revolutionary tendencies. In April
1783, Frederick the Great informed Charles of Hesse that the Berlin lodges had
documents belonging to the Minervals or Illuminati which contained appalling
material, and asked if he had heard of them. All Berlin masons were now warned
against the order, which was now accused of Socinianism, and of using the
liberal writings of Voltaire and others, alongside the tolerance of
Freemasonry, to undermine all religion. In November 1783, the Three Globes
described the Illuminati as a masonic sect which sought to undermine
Christianity and turn Freemasonry into a political system. Their final anathema,
in November 1784, refused to recognize any Illuminati as Freemasons.
In Austria, the Illuminati were blamed for anti-religious
pamphlets that had recently appeared. The Rosicrucians spied on Joseph von
Sonnenfels and other suspected Illuminati, and their campaign of denunciation
within Freemasonry completely shut down Illuminati recruitment in Tyrol.
The Bavarian Illuminati, whose existence was already known
to the Rosicrucians from an informant, were further betrayed by the reckless
actions of Ferdinand Maria Baader, an Areopagite who now joined the
Rosicrucians. Shortly after his admission it was made known to his superiors
that he was one of the Illuminati, and he was informed that he could not be a
member of both organizations. His letter of resignation stated that the
Rosicrucians did not possess secret knowledge, and ignored the truly
Illuminated, specifically identifying Lodge Theodore as an Illuminati Lodge.
Internal dissent
As the Illuminati embraced Freemasonry and expanded outside
Bavaria, the council of the Areopagites was replaced by an ineffective
"Council of Provincials". The Areopagites, however, remained as
powerful voices within the Order, and began again to bicker with Weishaupt as
soon as Knigge left Munich. Weishaupt responded by privately slandering his
perceived enemies in letters to his perceived friends.
More seriously, Weishaupt succeeded in alienating Knigge.
Weishaupt had ceded considerable power to Knigge in deputizing him to write the
ritual, power he now sought to regain. Knigge had elevated the Order from a
tiny anti-clerical club to a large organisation, and felt that his work was
under-acknowledged. Weishaupt's continuing anti-clericalism clashed with
Knigge's mysticism, and recruitment of mystically inclined Freemasons was a
cause of friction with Weishaupt and other senior Illuminati, such as Ditfurth.
Matters came to a head over the grade of Priest. The consensus among many of
the Illuminati was that the ritual was florid and ill-conceived, and the regalia
puerile and expensive. Some refused to use it, others edited it. Weishaupt
demanded that Knigge rewrite the ritual. Knigge pointed out that it was already
circulated, with Weishaupt's blessing, as ancient. This fell on deaf ears.
Weishaupt now claimed to other Illuminati that the Priest ritual was flawed
because Knigge had invented it. Offended, Knigge now threatened to tell the
world how much of the Illuminati ritual he had made up. Knigge's attempt to
create a convention of the Areopagites proved fruitless, as most of them
trusted him even less than they trusted Weishaupt. In July 1784 Knigge left the
order by agreement, under which he returned all relevant papers, and Weishaupt
published a retraction of all slanders against him. In forcing Knigge out, Weishaupt deprived the
order of its best theoretician, recruiter, and apologist.
Decline
The final decline of the Illuminati was brought about by the
indiscretions of their own Minervals in Bavaria, and especially in Munich. In
spite of efforts by their superiors to curb loose talk, politically dangerous
boasts of power and criticism of monarchy caused the "secret" order's
existence to become common knowledge, along with the names of many important
members. The presence of Illuminati in positions of power now led to some
public disquiet. There were Illuminati in many civic and state governing
bodies. In spite of their small number, there were claims that success in a
legal dispute depended on the litigant's standing with the order. The Illuminati
were blamed for several anti-religious publications then appearing in Bavaria.
Much of this criticism sprang from vindictiveness and jealousy, but it is clear
that many Illuminati court officials gave preferential treatment to their
brethren. In Bavaria, the energy of their two members of the Ecclesiastical
Council had one of them elected treasurer. Their opposition to Jesuits resulted
in the banned order losing key academic and church positions. In Ingolstadt,
the Jesuit heads of department were replaced by Illuminati.
Alarmed, Charles Theodore and his government banned all
secret societies including the Illuminati.
A government edict dated 2 March 1785 "seems to have been deathblow
to the Illuminati in Bavaria". Weishaupt had fled and documents and
internal correspondence, seized in 1786 and 1787, were subsequently published
by the government in 1787. Von Zwack's
home was searched and much of the group's literature was disclosed.
Barruel and Robison
Between 1797 and 1798, Augustin Barruel's Memoirs
Illustrating the History of Jacobinism and John Robison's Proofs of a
Conspiracy publicized the theory that the Illuminati had survived and
represented an ongoing international conspiracy. This included the claim that
it was behind the French Revolution. Both books proved to be very popular,
spurring reprints and paraphrases by others. A prime example of this is Proofs of the Real
Existence, and Dangerous Tendency, Of Illuminism by Reverend Seth Payson,
published in 1802. Some of the response
to this was critical, for example Jean-Joseph Mounier's On the Influence
Attributed to Philosophers, Free-Masons, and to the Illuminati on the
Revolution of France.
The works of Robison and Barruel made their way to the
United States and across New England. The Rev. Jedidiah Morse, an orthodox
Congregational minister and geographer, was among those who delivered sermons
against the Illuminati. In fact, one of the first accounts of the Illuminati to
be printed in the United States was Jedidiah Morse's Fast Day sermon of 9 May
1798. Morse had been alerted to the publication in Europe of Robison's Proofs
of a Conspiracy by a letter from the Rev. John Erskine of Edinburgh, and he
read Proofs shortly after copies published in Europe arrived by ship in March
of that year. Other anti-Illuminati writers, such as Timothy Dwight, soon
followed in their condemnation of the imagined group of conspirators.
Printed sermons were followed by newspaper accounts, and
these figured in the partisan political discourse leading up to the 1800 U.S.
presidential election. The subsequent
panic also contributed to the development of gothic literature in the United
States. At least two novels from the period make reference to the crisis:
Ormond; or, The Secret Witness (1799) and Julia, and the Illuminated Baron
(1800). Some scholars, moreover, have linked the panic over the alleged
Illuminati conspiracy to fears about immigration from the Caribbean and about
potential slave rebellions. Concern died
down in the first decade of the 1800s, although it revived from time to time in
the Anti-Masonic movement of the 1820s and 30s.
Modern Illuminati
Several recent and present-day fraternal organizations claim
to be descended from the original Bavarian Illuminati and openly use the name
"Illuminati". Some of these groups use a variation on the name
"The Illuminati Order" in the name of their own organizations, while
others, such as the Ordo Templi Orientis, have "Illuminati" as a
level within their organization’s hierarchy. However, there is no evidence that
these present-day groups have any real connection to the historic order. They
have not amassed significant political power or influence, and most, rather
than trying to remain secret, promote unsubstantiated links to the Bavarian
Illuminati as a means of attracting membership.
Legacy
In conspiracy theories
The Illuminati did not survive their suppression in Bavaria;
their further mischief and plottings in the work of Barruel and Robison must be
thus considered as the invention of the writers. Conspiracy theorists and writers such as Mark
Dice have argued that the Illuminati have survived to this day.
Many conspiracy theories propose that world events are being
controlled and manipulated by a secret society calling itself the Illuminati. Conspiracy theorists have claimed that many
notable people were or are members of the Illuminati. Presidents of the United
States are a common target for such claims.
Other theorists contend that a variety of
historical events were orchestrated by the Illuminati, from the French
Revolution, the Battle of Waterloo and the assassination of U.S. President John
F. Kennedy, to an alleged communist plot to hasten the "New World
Order" by infiltrating the Hollywood film industry.
No comments:
Post a Comment