THE MURDER OF LORETTA JONES
A True Crime Story — The Cold Case That Refused to Die
Price, Utah | July 1970–November 2016
This is a heartbreaking true-crime story about a young mother's brutal murder, a four-year-old girl's memories, and a detective who refused to let a decades-old investigation disappear.
One important detail: Loretta's murder was eventually solved. Thomas Edward Egley, the original suspect, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in October 2016 and was sentenced the following month. We can build the story toward that resolution while exploring the investigative setbacks, forgotten evidence, and Heidi's lifelong search for justice. Utah Attorney General
Chapter 1: Mommy Is Dead
Price, Utah — July 31, 1970
The morning of July 31, 1970, began like any other summer morning in Price, Utah.
But inside a modest home on East 400 South, a four-year-old girl was about to discover something no child should ever have to experience.
Her name was Heidi Jones.
Her mother, 23-year-old Loretta Marie Jones, had been her entire world. The two shared a home, a life, and the ordinary routines of a young mother raising her little girl.
There was no way Heidi could have understood that the previous evening would be the last time she would see her mother alive.
The night before, July 30, Loretta had been seen talking with a neighbor outside her home at approximately nine o'clock.
Nothing about that encounter suggested the horror that would follow.
Sometime later, violence entered the house.
Loretta was attacked, sexually assaulted, and stabbed repeatedly. Her injuries were catastrophic.
But the person responsible was gone.
The following morning, Heidi woke up and made her way toward the bedroom doorway.
What she saw through the keyhole would remain with her for the rest of her life.
Her mother was lying motionless on the living room floor.
Heidi did not understand death. She was only four years old. But she understood that something was terribly wrong.
She ran from the house.
A neighbor boy was nearby, and Heidi delivered words that would become permanently associated with the case.
"I think my mommy is dead."
Neighbors rushed to help. Police were contacted, and soon officers arrived at the residence.
Inside, they found Loretta Jones.
The young mother was dead.
The investigation immediately became a homicide inquiry.
Price Police Chief Art Poloni and Carbon County Sheriff Albert Passic worked together to determine who had entered Loretta's home and why.
There were no obvious signs of forced entry.
That detail complicated the investigation. Had Loretta known her attacker? Had she willingly allowed someone inside? Or had the killer found another way into the house?
Investigators began questioning people who knew Loretta.
One name quickly emerged: Thomas Edward Egley.
Egley had previously dated Loretta. He was questioned by investigators, and circumstances surrounding his whereabouts raised concerns.
But there was a problem.
Suspicion was not evidence.
Despite the early investigation, authorities could not establish enough evidence to secure a conviction.
For Heidi, however, the investigation was only beginning.
She had lost her mother before she was old enough to understand what losing someone truly meant.
And the man she would eventually identify as responsible for her mother's death would remain free for decades.
The case would grow cold.
Witnesses would die.
Evidence would disappear.
And the little girl who had run from her home that morning would grow into a woman who refused to let the world forget Loretta Jones.
Forty-six years later, that determination would finally change everything.
Historical note
The initial investigation included questioning Egley, who was arrested and charged in 1970. However, the case was dismissed after a preliminary hearing because prosecutors had not presented sufficient evidence to proceed. The investigation would eventually be reopened in 2009 at Heidi's request. The Salt Lake Tribune
Next Chapter — Chapter 2: The Man Who Walked Free
We'll explore:
Thomas Egley's relationship with Loretta.
Why investigators initially suspected him.
The evidence presented in 1970.
Why the judge dismissed the case.
Heidi's memories and the identification that would haunt the investigation for decades.
THE MURDER OF LORETTA JONES
Chapter 2: The Man Who Walked Free
Price, Utah — 1970
The murder of Loretta Jones shocked the small community of Price, Utah.
A young mother had been brutally killed inside her own home. Her four-year-old daughter had discovered her body. And somewhere in the community, the person responsible was walking free.
Investigators needed answers.
One name had already attracted their attention: Thomas Edward Egley.
Egley was not a stranger to Loretta. The two had dated, and investigators were interested in understanding the nature of their relationship and whether it had ended badly.
But establishing a motive was only one part of solving a murder.
Police needed evidence.
The First Suspect
During the original investigation, Egley reportedly acknowledged being in Price on the night Loretta was killed.
However, investigators could not establish sufficient evidence connecting him to the crime.
His whereabouts and activities became important questions.
Why had he been in Price that evening?
What had happened between him and Loretta?
And could anyone establish exactly where he had been during the hours surrounding her murder?
Investigators pursued the available leads, but the case was not coming together.
The medical examination had established that Loretta suffered multiple stab wounds. Her injuries were consistent with a violent and deeply personal attack.
The crime scene offered investigators a starting point, but the physical evidence available in 1970 would ultimately prove insufficient to secure a prosecution.
November 5, 1970: The Hearing
Several months after Loretta's murder, Egley faced a preliminary hearing.
The prosecution needed to demonstrate that sufficient evidence existed to move forward with the murder charge.
But the hearing did not produce the outcome investigators wanted.
Judge Tom Platis dismissed the case, determining that the evidence presented was insufficient to send Egley to trial.
The decision meant Egley would not face a murder trial.
He walked out of the courthouse.
A photograph published in the local newspaper captured him leaving the building wearing a flannel shirt.
For investigators, the dismissal represented a devastating setback.
For Loretta's family, it meant that the person they believed might have been responsible would not be held accountable.
And for Heidi, it meant growing up without her mother and without answers.
A Family Left Behind
Heidi was too young to understand court proceedings, legal arguments, or the burden of proving a murder case.
She understood something much simpler.
Her mother was gone.
As the years passed, she grew older, but the circumstances surrounding Loretta's death never stopped following her.
She remembered her mother.
She remembered the tragedy.
And she remembered the name, Thomas Egley.
Her belief about who had killed Loretta would remain with her throughout her life.
Meanwhile, Egley left Utah.
In 1971, he moved to Rocky Ford, Colorado.
The years continued.
People moved away. Memories faded. Potential witnesses died.
The murder investigation gradually became one of those cases that communities feared might never be solved.
The Evidence That Disappeared
Decades later, when investigators examined the original case, they discovered another obstacle.
Important evidence and investigative paperwork had been lost over time.
Among the missing items was a vaginal swab containing a semen sample collected during the original investigation.
That evidence might have provided an opportunity for modern DNA testing.
But it was no longer available.
The passage of time had taken away more than witnesses.
It had taken away opportunities.
Yet the case was not completely forgotten.
Heidi continued asking questions.
She wanted someone to look at the investigation again. She wanted someone to examine what had happened to her mother with fresh eyes.
She wanted justice.
She did not know that an unexpected encounter with an old schoolmate would eventually give her that opportunity.
A Chance Meeting
In 2009, Heidi encountered David Brewer, a former schoolmate who was now working as a sergeant with the Carbon County Sheriff's Office.
Their conversation turned toward their lives and what they were doing.
When Heidi learned Brewer was a law enforcement officer, she brought up her mother's murder.
It was a case that had haunted her for nearly four decades.
Brewer listened.
Unlike the investigators who had worked the case in 1970, he had access to modern investigative techniques and the possibility of revisiting old evidence.
He agreed to look into it.
The investigation that had stalled in 1970 was about to begin again.
And this time, the detective would have something the original investigators had not fully appreciated:
A daughter who had never stopped searching.
The name Thomas Egley was about to return to the center of the investigation.
Historical sources
The chapter draws on contemporary reporting and official records:
KSL — Man Arrested, Charged 46 Years Later in Rape and Murder
Utah Attorney General — Charges Filed in Loretta Jones Cold Case
Coming Next: Chapter 3 — The Case Reopened
Detective David Brewer begins retracing the investigation.
We'll explore:
Heidi's determination to find justice.
Brewer's first examination of the decades-old case.
The missing evidence and witnesses.
The decision to investigate Egley's life in Colorado.
The discovery of information that could finally change everything.
THE MURDER OF LORETTA JONES
Chapter 3: The Case Reopened
Price, Utah — 2009
Forty years had passed since Loretta Jones was murdered.
Four decades.
For most people in Price, Utah, the tragedy had become an old story. The young mother who had been brutally killed in her home was remembered by some, but the investigation had long since disappeared from public attention.
For Heidi Jones Asay, however, time had never erased anything.
She had grown up without her mother. She had lived with unanswered questions, incomplete memories, and the knowledge that the person responsible had never been brought to justice.
She wanted answers.
And in 2009, an unexpected meeting would give her a new opportunity to find them.
An Encounter at the Helper Arts Festival
Heidi encountered David Brewer, a former high school classmate who was now a sergeant with the Carbon County Sheriff's Office.
The conversation began casually.
They had not seen each other in years, and they exchanged updates about their lives.
When Heidi learned about Brewer's position in law enforcement, she realized she might finally have someone willing to listen.
She brought up her mother's murder.
Loretta Jones.
The unsolved 1970 homicide.
The investigation that had failed.
The man who had once been charged but walked free.
Heidi explained that she had never stopped wanting justice.
Brewer listened.
He could have treated it as another old case with little chance of resolution. Instead, something about Heidi's determination convinced him to take a closer look.
He asked her to bring whatever information she possessed to the sheriff's office.
She did.
And the investigation began again.
Starting With Almost Nothing
Brewer quickly discovered that reopening the case would be considerably more difficult than he had anticipated.
The original investigation had been conducted in 1970.
Modern DNA technology did not exist.
Evidence-storage procedures were different.
Investigative records were not always preserved in the organized manner expected today.
The original case file could not immediately be located.
Brewer began searching.
He and other officers examined the former county courthouse, including the basement where evidence had historically been stored.
They searched through old records and boxes.
Nothing.
The detective eventually learned that former Carbon County Sheriff Albert Passic, who had participated in the original investigation, had died in 2007.
There was a possibility that some of the original paperwork had been stored at Passic's home.
Unfortunately, his family had later discovered that the basement had flooded. Numerous papers and belongings had been discarded.
Whether Loretta's case file had been among them was never established.
One particularly important piece of evidence was also missing: a vaginal swab collected during the original examination that contained a semen sample.
In 1970, investigators could not have imagined how valuable that sample might become decades later.
Now, with DNA technology available, it could potentially have provided a direct connection to the person responsible.
But it was gone.
Brewer had to work around the loss.
Rebuilding the Crime Scene
Rather than surrendering to the missing evidence, Brewer began reconstructing the original investigation.
He obtained the medical examiner's report.
He reviewed surviving investigative information.
He searched newspaper archives and located people who had been connected to the case.
Some witnesses were still alive.
Others had died.
The detective began contacting people across the country, hoping to recover details that might have seemed insignificant in 1970 but could become important with modern investigative methods.
He also worked to create a digital representation of Loretta's home.
He examined the layout, considered possible entry and exit routes, and studied the location where Loretta had been found.
Even the doorway beads hanging near the crime scene received attention.
Investigators explored whether they might have retained traces of blood.
Every surviving detail mattered.
The Man in Colorado
There was one person Brewer could not ignore.
Thomas Edward Egley.
Egley had been questioned and charged in connection with Loretta's murder in 1970.
The charge had been dismissed, but that did not mean investigators were prohibited from examining him again.
Brewer eventually located Egley in Rocky Ford, Colorado.
He and another investigator traveled there to speak with him.
The encounter was revealing in its own way.
According to Brewer's later account, Egley appeared to recognize why the investigators had come.
When Brewer introduced himself and explained that they wanted to discuss something, Egley reportedly responded that it was probably about Loretta's murder.
But Egley denied involvement.
The detective had no confession.
He had no recovered murder weapon.
And he still lacked the original physical evidence.
Nevertheless, he continued building the case.
A Case That Refused to Stay Buried
By 2014, Brewer had assembled a substantial body of circumstantial information.
He submitted the investigation to Carbon County prosecutors for review.
But prosecutors declined to file charges at that time.
The missing original reports and physical evidence created serious problems.
The defense would be entitled to examine the original investigation materials, and the prosecution faced difficulties explaining why so much documentation could not be produced.
It was another setback.
For Heidi, it must have felt painfully familiar.
Once again, her mother's killer had not been brought to justice.
But Brewer was not finished.
He continued examining Egley's history and interviewing people connected to his life.
One conversation would eventually become especially important.
It involved a woman who knew Egley and had information that investigators had not previously uncovered.
She would tell Brewer things that changed the direction of the investigation.
And suddenly, the detective who had spent years trying to reconstruct a crime from missing evidence had a new way forward.
The next breakthrough would not come from a forgotten laboratory sample.
It would come from a conversation.
And it would lead investigators back to the night Loretta Jones died.
Historical sources
The chapter is based primarily on contemporary investigative reporting and official statements:
Coming Next: Chapter 4 — The Forgotten Photograph
A photograph and surviving investigative details help investigators reconstruct Loretta's final hours.
We'll explore:
What Heidi remembered about the evening before her mother's murder.
The significance of the people who encountered Loretta that night.
The investigation into Egley's movements.
The woman who eventually provided investigators with critical information.
The beginning of a breakthrough that would lead to a confession in 2016.
Historical distinction: The original physical evidence was largely lost. The eventual breakthrough came through renewed interviews, investigative work, and Egley's admissions—not simply through DNA evidence. archive.sltrib.com
No comments:
Post a Comment