Donald Harvey

 

Donald Harvey (April 15, 1952 – March 30, 2017) was an American serial killer who claimed to have murdered 87 people, though official estimates are between 37 and 57 victims. He was able to do this during his time as a hospital orderly. His spree took place between 1970 and 1987.

Harvey claimed to have begun killing to "ease the pain" of patients—mostly cardiac patients—by smothering them with their pillows. However, he gradually grew to enjoy killing and became a self-described "angel of death." At the time of his death, Harvey was serving 28 life sentences at the Toledo Correctional Institution in Toledo, Ohio, having pled guilty to murder charges to avoid execution.

Early life

Donald Harvey was born in Hamilton, Ohio on April 15, 1952, the oldest of three children born to Ray and Goldie Harvey. He was raised in the tiny Appalachian town of Booneville, Kentucky, where his parents were struggling tobacco farmers and members of the local Baptist church. From the ages of five to eighteen, Harvey was sexually molested by both an uncle and a neighbor, but he told no one except his sister, and only after the abuse ended. Harvey dropped out of school in the ninth grade, but he earned a correspondence school GED in 1968. After an arrest for burglary in March 1971, Harvey enlisted in the United States Air Force, but was discharged after nine months due to two suicide attempts; after these nervous breakdowns, he came to terms with his homosexuality.

Murders

Harvey began working in hospitals at the age of 18. His first medical job was as an orderly at the Marymount Hospital in London, Kentucky. He later confessed that during the ten-month period he worked at the hospital, he killed at least a dozen patients. His second victim was killed in the room with Danny George, a twelve-year-old child. Harvey was insistent that he killed purely out of a sense of empathy for the suffering of those who were terminally ill, but also admitted that many of the killings were committed were due to anger at the victims. Unusual for a serial killer, Harvey had no specific target; his victims were men and women of all ages, races, ethnicities and backgrounds. The only thing they had in common was that they were all cardiac patients.

The full extent of Harvey's crimes may never be known since so many were undetected for so long. He did not use any particular modus operandi and used many methods to kill his victims, such as: arsenic, cyanide, insulin, suffocation, miscellaneous poisons, morphine, turning off ventilators, administration of fluid tainted with hepatitis B and/or HIV (which resulted in a hepatitis infection, but no HIV infection, and illness rather than death), and insertion of a coat hanger into a catheter, causing an abdominal puncture and subsequent peritonitis. Cyanide and arsenic were his most-used methods, with Harvey administering them via food or injections. The majority of Harvey's crimes took place at the Marymount Hospital, the Cincinnati V.A. Medical Hospital, and Cincinnati's Drake Memorial Hospital. At various times, he worked as an orderly or an autopsy assistant.

Harvey did not limit his victims to helpless hospital patients. When he suspected his lover and roommate Carl Hoeweler of infidelity, he poisoned Hoeweler's food with arsenic so he would be too ill to leave their apartment. He poisoned two of his neighbors—sickening one, Diane Alexander, by putting hepatitis serum in her drink, and killing the other, Helen Metzger, by putting arsenic in her pie. He also killed Hoeweler's father Henry with arsenic.

Investigation

After keeping his crimes hidden for seventeen years, Harvey slipped in March 1987. An autopsy on John Powell, who had died abruptly after spending several months on life support following a motorcycle accident, revealed large amounts of cyanide in his system. Harvey became a person of interest when investigators learned he had been forced to resign from the Cincinnati VA hospital after he was caught stealing body parts for occult rituals. At the time, most hospitals did not vet orderlies as closely as doctors or nurses. When they brought Harvey in for questioning, he confessed to Powell's murder, claiming he had euthanized him with cyanide.

Pat Minarcin, then an anchor at Cincinnati station WCPO-TV, found it unlikely that someone who had spent almost two decades caring for patients could suddenly kill one without having killed before. During his report on the night of Harvey's arrest, Minarcin asked on-air if there had been any other deaths. It was soon revealed that several nurses at Drake had raised concerns with administrators upon noticing a spike in deaths while Harvey was employed there, but they had been ordered to keep quiet. Not wanting to chance that he would be acquitted, the nurses contacted Minarcin and told him that there was evidence Harvey killed at least ten more people. Over the next several months, Minarcin investigated the suspicious deaths and amassed enough evidence to air a half-hour special report detailing evidence that linked Harvey to at least 24 murders in a four-year period. Harvey had been able to stay under the radar in part because he worked in an area of Drake where patients were not expected to survive.

When Harvey's court-appointed lawyer, Bill Whalen, was briefed in advance about Minarcin's findings, he immediately asked Harvey if he had killed anyone else. Harvey replied that by his "estimate," he had killed as many as 70 people. Whalen knew that if prosecutors could link Harvey to more than one murder, Ohio law allowed them to seek the death penalty. In a bid to save his client's life, Whalen offered prosecutors a plea bargain—if the death penalty were taken off the table, Harvey would accept a sentence of life without parole and confess to all of his murders. The prosecutors agreed. In a marathon session with prosecutors, Harvey admitted to killing 24 people.

In August 1987, Harvey pled guilty to 24 counts of first-degree murder. In accordance with the plea agreement, he was sentenced to three concurrent terms of life in prison. The plea agreement allowed prosecutors to seek the death penalty if more murders came to light. With this in mind, that November Harvey pled guilty in Laurel County (Kentucky) Circuit Court to killing nine patients at Marymount in the 1970s. He was sentenced to life plus 20 years, to run concurrently with the Ohio sentence. Ultimately, Harvey pled guilty to 37 murders. However, he confessed to killing as many as 50 people.

Harvey was admitted to the Ohio prison system on October 26, 1987.

Death

On March 28, 2017, authorities reported that Harvey had been found in his cell severely beaten. He died on March 30, 2017. On May 3, 2019, fellow inmate James Elliott was charged with aggravated murder and other charges related to the death of Donald Harvey. In September 2019, he was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison after pleading guilty to killing Harvey. The sentence was originally ordered to run consecutively to his other sentences, but was later changed to run concurrently. Elliott would have become eligible for parole in 2046, when he would have been 71 years old.

Known victims

Logan Evans      88           M            Kentucky             May 31, 1970      Intentional, non-premeditated Suffocation; smothered with a pillow and plastic bag

James Tyree       69           M            Kentucky             May 31, 1970      Accidental           Harvey gave Tyree the wrong catheter, causing him to vomit blood and die

Elizabeth Wyatt                  42        F              Kentucky             June 22, 1970     Intentional, non-premeditated Suffocation; cut off her oxygen supply

Eugene McQueen            43           M            Kentucky             July 10, 1970       Intentional, non-premeditated Drowning; turned over on his back, causing him to drown in his own fluids

Harvey Williams                82           M            Kentucky             July 12, 1970       Accidental           Cardiac arrest; was given a faulty oxygen tank

Ben Gilbert          81           M            Kentucky             July 24-28, 1970 Intentional, premeditated           Organ infection; had knocked Harvey out with a urinal; Harvey gave him a catheter that was too large and then put a straightened coat hanger through it and into Gilbert's urethra, puncturing his bladder and bowel; went into instant shock and a coma, where he died four days later

Maude Nichols  N/A        F              Kentucky             August 15, 1970                Intentional, non-premeditated Cardiac arrest; was given a faulty oxygen tank

William Bowling                58           M            Kentucky             August 30, 1970                Intentional, non-premeditated Heart attack; cut off his oxygen supply

Viola Reed Wyran            63           F              Kentucky             November 4, 1970           Intentional, premeditated           Suffocation, attempted to kill her by smothering her with a pillow and plastic bag but was interrupted; later killed her by giving her a faulty oxygen tank

Margaret Harrison          91           F              Kentucky             December 6, 1970            Intentional, non-premeditated Drug overdose; overdosed her on Demerol, codeine, and morphine

Sam Carroll         80           M            Kentucky             January 6, 1971 Intentional, premeditated           Suffocation; given a faulty oxygen tank

Maggie Rawlins                  N/A      F              Kentucky             January 15, 1971               Intentional, premeditated           Suffocation; smothered with a pillow and a plastic bag between it and her face

Silas Butner        62           M            Kentucky             January 23, 1971               Intentional, non-premeditated Suffocation; given a faulty oxygen tank

John V. Combs  68           M            Kentucky             January 26, 1971               Intentional, premeditated           Suffocation; attempted to smother him with a plastic bag, but instead gave him a faulty oxygen tank

Milton Bryant Sasser      91           M            Kentucky             March 14, 1971  Intentional, premeditated           Drug overdose; overdosed him on morphine

Helen Metzger   63           F              Ohio      April 10, 1983     Intentional, premeditated           Internal injuries; after an argument with Harvey, Metzger was given arsenic after a tracheotomy, causing paralysis and hemorrhaging

Henry Hoeweler                  82         M            Ohio      1983 (unspecified date)                Intentional, premeditated           Stroke and kidney failure; poisoned with arsenic

Howard Vetter  N/A        M            Ohio      1983 (unspecified date)                Accidental           Heart attack; drank alcohol Harvey had poisoned

Hiram Profitt      N/A        M            Ohio      September 19, 1984        Accidental           Drug overdose; overdosed him on heparin

James Peluso     65           M            Ohio      November 9, 1984           Intentional, premeditated           Cardiac arrest; poisoned with arsenic, was one of Harvey's ex-lovers

Edward Wilson  N/A        M            Ohio      March 18-25, 1985           Intentional, non-premeditated Poisoning; poisoned with arsenic, died 5 days after poisoning

Nathani J. Watson          65           M            Ohio      April 8, 1986        Intentional, premeditated           Suffocation; smothered with a wet plastic garbage bag liner; unsuccessfully attempted several times prior

Leon Nelson       64           M            Ohio      April 14, 1986     Intentional, non-premeditated Suffocation; smothered with a wet plastic garbage bag liner

Virgil Weddle     81           M            Ohio      April 19, 1986     Intentional, premeditated           Heart attack; poisoned with rat poison in his pudding

Lawrence Berndsen         N/A        M            Ohio      April 20-23, 1986               Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned repeatedly with rat poison; died three days later

Doris Nally          65           F              Ohio      May 2, 1986        Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with cyanide in her apple juice

Willie Johnson   N/A        M            Ohio      May-June 1986 (unspecified date)           Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; attempted to poison with arsenic repeatedly

Edward Schreibesis         63           M            Ohio      June 20, 1986     Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with arsenic in his soup

Robert Crockett                  80         M            Ohio      June 29, 1986     Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with cyanide in his I.V.

Donald Barney  91           M            Ohio      July 7, 1986         Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; fed cyanide through a feeding tube and injected it into his buttocks

James T. Woods               65           M            Ohio      July 25, 1986       Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with cyanide through his gastric tube

Ernst C. Frey       85           M            Ohio      August 16, 1986                Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with arsenic through his gastric tube

Milton Canter    85           M            Ohio      August 29, 1986                Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with cyanide through his nasal tube

Roger Evans       74           M            Ohio      September 17, 1986        Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with cyanide through his gastric tube

Clayborn Kendrick           N/A        M            Ohio      September 20, 1986        Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with cyanide through both his gastric tube and an injection into his testes

Albert Buehimann           69           M            Ohio      October 27, 1986              Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with cyanide dissolved in his cup of water

William Collins   85           M            Ohio      October 30, 1986              Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with cyanide dissolved in his orange juice

Henry Cody         78           M            Ohio      November 4, 1986           Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with cyanide dissolved in water through his gastric tube

Mose Thompson              65           M            Ohio      November 22, 1986         Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with cyanide through his nasal tube

Odas Day            72           M            Ohio      December 9, 1986            Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with a cyanide solution

Cleo Fish              67           F              Ohio      December 10, 1986         Intentional, non-premeditated Poisoning; poisoned with cyanide in her cranberry juice; removed a lock of her hair post-mortem and burned it

Leo Parker           47           M            Ohio      January 1, 1987 Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with cyanide in his feed bag

Margaret Kuckro             80           F              Ohio      February 5, 1987               Intentional, premeditated           poisoning; poisoned with cyanide in her orange juice

Stella Lemon      76           F              Ohio      February-March 16, 1987              Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with a cyanide solution

Joseph M. Pike  68           M            Ohio      March 6, 1987    Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with detachol

Hilda Leitz            82           F              Ohio      March 7, 1987    Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with detachol in her G-tube and her orange juice

John W. Powell   N/A      M            Ohio      March 7, 1987    Intentional, premeditated           Poisoning; poisoned with cyanide in his gastric feeding tube

Media

WCPO-TV's I-Team, created in 1988, and investigated Harvey's crimes. They received several awards for their efforts.

Autopsy covered Harvey's crimes in the 1995 episode "The Angel of Death".

Infamous Murders covered Harvey's case alongside two others in its first episode titles "Angels of Death" in 2001.

Dr. G: Medical Examiner covered the case in the episode "Killers Among Us" in 2009.

My Favorite Murder featured Harvey's case in is 110th released episode in 2018.

Harvey was mentioned along with Elizabeth Wettlaufer in the Season 14 episode of Criminal Minds titled "Broken Wing" in 2018.

And That's Why We Drink covers the case in its 159th episode titled "A Sinister Vibe Check and the Governor of Noodletown" in 2020.